TJ-eas.
HJ
2M12 i
.T71
Taxation of Technical Services Personnel:
Section 1706 of the Tax Reform Act of 1986
A Report to The Congress
Department of the Treasury
March 1991
,77/
Taxation of Technical Services Personnel:
Section 1706 of the Tax Reform Act of 1986
A Report to The Congress
•*^*-- '•'.*/
UBBAfiy-i.^-ft^'i
^t5lVk^^^
_ ^5030
TUMSURy-OEPABTMENi-
Department of the Treasury
March 1991
DEPARTMENT OF THE TREASURY
WASHINGTON
March 1991
ASSISTANT SECRETARY
The Honorable Dan Rostenkowski
Chai rman
Committee on Ways and Means
House of Representatives
Washington D. C. 20515
Dear Mr. Chairman:
Section 6072 of Public Law 100-647, the Technical and
Miscellaneous Revenue Act of 1988, provides that the Secretary of
the Treasury shall conduct a study of the treatment provided by
section 1706 of the Tax Reform Act of 1986 (relating to treatment
of certain technical personnel).
Pursuant to that section, I hereby submit the "Taxation
of Technical Services Personnel: Report on Section 1706 of the
Tax Reform Act of 1986."
I am sending a similar letter to Senator Lloyd Bentsen,
Chairman of the Committee on Finance.
YH^H8i-^ Sincerely,
Kenneth W. Gideon
A'ssistant Se
(Tax Policy)
■\i/^ iMTiiA*^30 "^'■'^■^' 'A'ssistant Secretary
''' ' (Tax Poli(
Enclosure
ASSISTANT SECRETARY
DEPARTMENT OF THE TREASURY
WASHINGTON
March 1991
The Honorable Lloyd Bentsen
Chairman
Committee on Finance
United States Senate
Washington D. C. 20510
Dear Mr. Chairman:
Section 6072 of Public Law 100-647, the Technical and
Miscellaneous Revenue Act of 1988, provides that the Secretary of
the Treasury shall conduct a study of the treatment provided by
section 1706 of the Tax Reform Act of 1986 (relating to treatment
of certain technical personnel).
Pursuant to that section, I hereby submit the "Taxation
of Technical Services Personnel: Report on Section 1706 of the
Tax Reform Act of 1986."
I am sending a similar letter to Representative Dan
Rostenkowski , Chairman of the Committee on Ways and Means.
Sincerely,
r(sciLd. %~J-^-^
Kenneth W, Gideon
Assistant Secretary
(Tax Policy)
Enclosure
TABLE OF CONTENTS
PART ONE: EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 1
CHAPTER 1: EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 3
I. BACKGROUND OF REPORT 3
n. REPORT MANDATE 4
m. EVALUATION OF ISSUES 4
IV. OPTIONS FOR FURTHER CONSIDERATION 6
PART TWO: BACKGROUND INFORMATION 9
CHAPTER 2: SOURCES OF EMPLOYEE MISCLASSIFICATION 11
I. OVERVIEW 11
n. DETERMINATION OF EMPLOYEE STATUS 12
m. DIFFERENCES IN TAX TREATMENT BETWEEN EMPLOYEES
AND INDEPENDENT CONTRACTORS 12
A. Differences Favoring Independent Contractor Status 12
B. Differences Favoring Employee Status 14
C. Five Hypothetical Examples of Differential Tax Treatment 15
D. Validity of Differences 26
CHAPTER 3: ORIGINS OF SECTION 1706 29
I. SECTION 530 29
n. SECTION 3509 31
m. SECTION 1706 32
PART THREE: DISCUSSION OF ISSUES 35
CHAPTER 4: GENERAL POLICY ISSUES 37
I. OVERVIEW 37
n. EFFICIENCY OF LABOR MARKETS 37
A. Arrangements Between Workers and Firms 37
B. Government Policy 40
m. NEUTRALITY IN TAX TREATMENT 40
A. Maintaining Labor Market Efficiency 40
B. Tax Equity 42
rV. ADMINISTRATIVE COSTS 45
V. NON-TAX POLICIES 46
CHAPTER 5: TAX COMPLIANCE ISSUES 47
L OVERVIEW 47
n. RATE OF MISCLASSIFICATION 47
m. RATE OF NONCOMPLIANCE 50
A. 1985 TCMP 51
B. 1984 SVC-1 Employee Survey 54
C. Summary 55
CHAPTER 6: TAX ADMINISTRATION ISSUES 57
I. OVERVIEW 57
n. ADMINISTRATIVE PROBLEMS WITH SECTION 1706 57
m. ADMINISTRATIVE PROBLEMS WITH COMMON LAW TESTS OF
EMPLOYEE STATUS 58
PART FOUR: APPENDICES 61
APPENDIX A: DIFFERENCES IN TREATMENT OF EMPLOYEES AND
INDEPENDENT CONTRACTORS-DETAILED ANALYSIS 63
I. OVERVIEW 63
n. FEDERAL TAX LAW 63
A. Employment Taxes 63
B. Income Taxes 66
C. Determination of Employee Status 75
m. OTHER LAWS 78
A. Federal Labor Laws 78
B. Patent and Copyright Laws 80
C. State Laws 80
D. Determination of Employee Status 81
IV. SUMMARY 82
APPENDIX B: COMMON LAW FACTORS USED TO DETERMINE EMPLOYEE
STATUS . 83
APPENDIX C: ADDITIONAL BACKGROUND TO TCMP AND SVC-1 85
I. TCMP 85
II. SVC-1 86
VI
LIST OF TABLES
Chapter 2
2-1 Major Differences in Treatment of Employees and Independent Contractors for
Federal Tax and Other Purposes 16
2-2 Comparison of Income and Taxation of $1,000 of Total Compensation for an
Employee or Independent Contractor, Worker with a Typical Mix of Fringe
Benefits and no Worker Expenses 18
2-3 Comparison of Income and Taxation of $1,000 of Total Compensation for an
Employee or Independent Contractor, Worker with a Typical Mix of Fringe
Benefits, no Worker Expenses, and 5 Percent Non-Compliance by the
Independent Contractor 20
2-4 Comparison of Income and Taxation of $1,000 of Total Compensation for an
Employee or Independent Contractor, Worker with a Typical Mix of Fringe
Benefits and Worker Expenses of 10 Percent 21
2-5 Comparison of Income and Taxation of $1,000 of Total Compensation for an
Employee or Independent Contractor, Worker with Only Statutory Benefits and
no Worker Expenses 23
2-6 Comparison of Income and Taxation of $1,000 of Total Compensation for an
Employee or Independent Contractor, Worker with Only Statutory Benefits, no
Worker Expenses, and a "Wedge" Between Employee and Independent
Contractor Total Compensation 25
Chapter 5
5-1 Percentage of Employers with Some Misclassified Employees, by Industry 49
5-2 Reporting of Income and Expenses by Employees and Independent Contractors . . 52
Appendix A
A-1 Tax-Favored Benefits Available to Employees and Independent Contractors .... 73
vu
PART ONE
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
CHAPTER 1: EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
I. BACKGROUND OF REPORT
Despite the wide variety of relationships between workers and firms, there are generally
only two classifications of workers for Federal tax purposes: self-employed workers (sometimes
called independent contractors) and employees. The proper classification is self-evident for
many workers; for others, it is ambiguous. When the proper classification is ambiguous, the
potential for worker misclassification increases. Inadvertent misclassification may occur if
employers lack sufficiently detailed guidance to determine the correct classification. In addition,
the various legal, economic, and tax consequences of the alternate classifications may provide
incentives for deliberate misclassification.
Historically, misclassification of employees as independent contractors was a concern
because self-employed workers faced significantly lower Social Security and Medicare tax rates
than the combined rate for employers and employees. Misclassification was perceived as
producing large losses of employment tax revenues. Now that self-employed workers face
Social Security and Medicare tax rates comparable to the combined rate for employees and
employers, concern about misclassification has shifted to potential losses of all tax revenues.
Income and employment tax revenues may be lower due to differences in the income and
employment tax bases and differences in compliance between employees and the self-employed.
In the late 1960s, when significant employment tax rate differentials still existed, the
Internal Revenue Service (IRS) began to increase its employment tax enforcement activities,
which previously had been sporadic, to address the misclassification of workers. Classification
of a worker directly affects employment tax obligations and indirectly affects a worker's income
tax treatment. As a result of the IRS' actions, the number of reclassifications increased
substantially. Many reclassifications resulted in large retroactive assessments against employers.
Congress subsequently took several actions to address taxpayer concerns about worker
reclassification. In section 530 of the Revenue Act of 1978 (section 530), it provided statutory
relief from reclassification for certain employers involved in employment tax controversies with
the IRS. Section 530 generally prohibited the IRS from challenging an employer's erroneous
treatment of an employee as an independent contractor for employment tax purposes if the
employer had a reasonable basis for such treatment and certain other requirements were met.
It also generally prohibited the IRS from issuing regulations or publishing revenue rulings
addressing the status of workers as employees or independent contractors for employment tax
purposes. Section 530 was initially intended as an interim measure. In 1982, Congress
extended it indefinitely, and also limited employer liabilities in certain cases of retroactive
reclassification.
Section 1706 of the Tax Reform Act of 1986 (section 1706) removed the statutory relief
of section 530, but only for taxpayers that broker the services of technical services workers, i.e.,
engineers, designers, drafters, computer programmers, systems analysts and other similarly-
skilled workers engaged in a similar line of work. Thus, section 1706 only applies in multi-
party situations involving (1) technical services workers, (2) companies that use the workers, and
(3) firms that supply or broker the services of the workers.
Section 1706 does not change the rules for classifying workers as employees or
independent contractors, nor does it change the legal status of anyone covered by the provision.
It only permits the IRS to interpret and enforce the underlying rules for employment tax
purposes for the covered technical services workers without regard to section 530. However,
in practice the worker's employment tax classification generally determines whether the worker
is treated as an employee or independent contractor for Federal income tax purposes.
n. REPORT MANDATE
This report was prepared in response to a congressional mandate in the Technical and
Miscellaneous Revenue Act of 1988 (TAMRA). Section 6072 of TAMRA directed the Secretary
of the Treasury or his delegate to conduct a study of the treatment provided by section 1706 of
the Tax Reform Act of 1986 (TRA 1986).
in. EVALUATION OF ISSUES
According to the Conference Report on TAMRA,' the Treasury report was to include
an evaluation of five issues. These issues, and the general findings of the report with respect
to each, are described below.
H.R. Conf. Rep. No. 1104, 100th Cong., 2d Sess. 167-68 (1988).
Administrability of section 1706. The Conference Report questioned whether there were
difficulties in the adniinistration of the provisions of section 1706. The report finds that:
• Section 1706 itself presents few administrative problems, particularly in comparison with
section 530;
• Section 1706 actually improves the administrability of the present-law rules for
classifying individuals as employees or independent contractors by partially repealing the
prohibition in section 530 against the issuance of guidance; but
• The occupations covered by section 1706 could be clarified {see Chapter 6, section 11).
Abuses in the reporting of income by independent contractors. The Conference Report
questioned whether there were any abuses in the reporting of income by independent contractors
that would justify the adoption of section 1706, including any evidence of greater noncompliance
by independent contractors when compared to employees. The report finds that:
• Existing IRS data suggest that there are errors in the classification of employees as
independent contractors and in the reporting of income by such individuals, which may
call for legislative or administrative changes—
► Underreporting of income by such individuals, and the more favorable treatment
of independent contractor trade or business expenses, reduce tax revenue;
► Misclassification of employees as independent contractors increases tax revenues,
however, and tends to offset the revenue loss from undercompliance by such
individuals, because direct compensation to independent contractors is substituted
for tax-favored employee fringe benefits;
• Evidence suggests that compliance is somewhat better for technical services workers who
are classified as independent contractors than for workers in general who are classified
as independent contractors {see Chapter 5).
Chilling effect of section 1706 on the ability of technical services personnel to get work. The
Conference Report questioned the effect of section 1706 on the ability of technical services
personnel to get work. The report concludes that:
• Section 1706 does not affect the cost to firms of technical services workers relative to
other workers, and does not affect the demand for firms' products; it is unlikely,
therefore, that section 1706 affects the overall ability of technical services workers to get
work;
• Section 1706 may, however, have had some transitory effects on the ability of some
workers to find work in their accustomed classification (jee Chapter 4).
Administrability of the present-law standards for classifying individuals as employees or
independent contractors. The Conference Report questioned whether the present law standards
for distinguishing between employees and independent contractors were administrable. The
report finds that:
• The task of classifying workers as employees or independent contractors under the 20-
factor common law tests generally used under present law can be difficult, in particular
in the multi-party situations affected by section 1706;
• Section 530 has exacerbated this problem by preventing theTRS from issuing guidance
in this area for over ten years; and
• Section 1706 may have improved tax administration by permitting the IRS to issue
guidance with respect to certain workers and by denying the section 530 safe harbors to
certain employers {see Chapter 6, section IE).
Equity of distinguishing between independent contractors who work through brokers and those
who do not. The Conference Report questioned the equity of providing rules that distinguish
between independent contractors who work through brokers and those who do not. The report
finds that:
• This distinction unnecessarily limits the beneficial effects of section 1706, and may have
an adverse effect on the efficiency of the labor markets for such workers;
• Data are not available, however, to determine whether the distinction can be justified on
the basis of differences in compliance rates between the two groups {see Chapter 4).
IV. OPTIONS FOR FURTHER CONSIDERATION
The significance of the effects of section 1706 must be viewed in the context of existing
substantive tax differences between independent contractors and employees, especially with
respect to the exclusion of fringe benefits from gross income, the deductibility of employee
business expenses, and differences in the Social Security and Medicare tax base. In that context,
and based on the findings of this report, the following options are presented for further
consideration and analysis:
• Eliminate the difference in treatment under section 1706 between technical services
workers working through brokers and those not working through brokers. This
difference is difficult to justify on equity or other policy grounds. (See Chapter 4.)
• Clarify the occupations covered by section 1706. Difficulties in determining the
occupations covered by section 1706 present an administrative problem. {See Chapter
6.)
• Repeal the prohibition in section 530 against the issuance of guidance by the IRS
concerning employee status. This prohibition has significantly reduced taxpayers' ability
to classify workers correctly as employees or independent contractors and has
exacerbated the difficulty of applying the 20-factor common law standards. {See Chapter
6.)
PART TWO
BACKGROUND INFORMATION
CHAPTER 2: SOURCES OF EMPLOYEE MISCLASSIFICATION
I. OVERVIEW
A wide variety of relationships between service-providers and service-recipients exists
in the modem economy. They differ with respect to the degree of control exercised by the
service-recipient, whether the services are full-time or part-time, the method of compensation
(e.g. , salaried versus hourly), the level of material support provided by the service-recipient, and
many other factors. Despite this diversity, service-providers are generally grouped into one of
two broad categories for Federal tax purposes: employees and independent contractors.
Misclassification of individuals as employees or independent contractors results when
service-recipients and service-providers misapply the tests oised to distinguish employees from
independent contractors under the Code. Deliberate misclassification of employees as
independent contractors results in part from the fact that there are numerous differences under
the Internal Revenue Code (Code) between the treatment of employers and employees, on the
one hand, and independent contractors and their clients, on the other, and from the perception
that these differences systematically favor the second group.
Differences in treatment between employers and employees, on the one hand, and
independent contractors and their clients, on the other, also occur under a number of other
Federal and State laws, primarily those dealing with workers' compensation and unemployment
insurance, labor-management relations, employment discrimination, and other labor issues.
Misclassification designed to benefit from these differences in non-tax treatment can also
contribute to misclassification for Federal tax purposes, since inconsistent treatment of an
individual under these laws and Federal tax laws might invite scrutiny.
Misclassification of individuals as employees or independent contractors is problematic
to the extent that it circumvents a policy decision to limit certain tax benefits or burdens to one
group or the other, or results in a loss of revenue through noncompliance.
This chapter provides a general description of the factors used to distinguish employees
from independent contractors under Federal tax and other laws, and of the differences in the
treatment of employees and independent contractors that may encourage misclassification under
each. A more detailed description of these issues is provided in Appendix A.
11
12
n. DETERMINATION OF EMPLOYEE STATUS
The status of an individual as an employee or independent contractor for purposes of
Federal employment, income and other tax laws is, with few exceptions, determined under the
common law tests for determining whether an employment relationship exists. These tests focus
on whether the service-recipient has the right to direct and control the service-provider, not only
as to the result to be accomplished by the work, but also as to the details and means by which
that result is accomplished. Over the years, the IRS has identified 20 important factors useful
in determining whether the common law tests have been satisfied. These factors are listed in
Appendix B.
The status of an individual as an employee or independent contractor for purposes of
Federal and State labor and related laws is generally determined under standards that resemble
the control-based common law standards applied under the Code. Depending on the purpose of
the law involved, however, different factors are often emphasized in making this determination.
Thus, IRS determinations of employee status based on the common law tests are generally
persuasive but not determinative in other areas, and it is possible for an individual to be
classified as an employee for some purposes and as an independent contractor for others.
m. DIFFERENCES IN TAX TREATMENT BETWEEN EMPLOYEES AND
INDEPENDENT CONTRACTORS
Current law does not consistently favor status as either an employee or an independent
contractor. Employers and employees are treated differently than independent contractors and
their clients under a number of Federal and State laws, however. Thus, depending on individual
circumstances, misclassification may sometimes be advantageous to the service-provider, the
service-recipient, or both.
A. Differences Favoring Independent Contractor Status
Federal Tax Law. Prior to 1982, compensation earned by independent contractors was
taxed at substantially lower rates under the Social Security and Medicare tax provisions of the
Code than wage income, apparently creating a significant incentive for misclassification.^
Subsequent legislation has essentially eliminated this important difference. The Social Security,
^ To some extent, however, the rate differential may have been offset by differences in the
compensation base to which the taxes applied.
13
Medicare, and income tax provisions of the Code may still favor classification as an independent
contractor, however, where an individual has a small or unpredictable cash flow or significant
employee business expenses. This is primarily because:
(1) Independent contractors face significantly fewer restrictions on their ability to
deduct trade or business expenses than employees. In particular, employees
generally may not deduct their trade or business expenses unless they "itemize"
their deductions on their tax returns, and then only to the extent the expenses
exceed two percent of their adjusted gross incomes from all sources. They must
also satisfy additional requirements before they may deduct their automobile
depreciation, home office, home computer and certain other expenses. These
requirements are difficult for many employees to meet and in some cases
constitute an effective barrier to a deduction.
(2) The estimated tax system used to collect Social Security, Medicare, and income
taxes from independent contractors largely avoids the problem of over-withhold-
ing that can result when an employee incurs large business expenses, has net
income that fluctuates during a year, or is employed for only part of a year. It
also generally permits later and less frequent payments than the withholding
system used to collect such taxes from employees.
As an essentially voluntary reporting system, the estimated tax system also provides fewer
checks against underreporting of income and taxes than the withholding system and may,
therefore, be favored by service-providers and service-recipients willing to violate the law and
risk detection on audit; it also does not ensure the collectability of taxes to the same extent as
the withholding system. Finally, the withholding system involves overhead costs, which
employers may seek to shift to employees by classifying them as independent contractors.
The unemployment insurance tax provisions of the Code (and corresponding State laws)
may in some cases also favor classification as an independent contractor. Independent
contractors and their clients generally are not subject to unemployment insurance taxes. On the
other hand, independent contractors generally are not eligible for unemployment insurance
benefits. Other things being equal, employers will have an incentive to classify a worker as an
independent contractor in order to avoid unemployment insurance taxes on an employee's wages
(and the administrative costs of remitting such taxes and complying with other associated
statutory requirements). Workers may prefer to be classified as independent contractors if they
are not (or perceive that they are not) dependent on a single employer for their income.
14
Other Laws. State and Federal labor and related laws may in some cases also favor
classification as an independent contractor. Such laws typically do not apply to independent
contractors, providing protection only to employees. This is generally beneficial to clients of
independent contractors, since it may allow them to avoid the direct costs of providing additional
benefits and protections to the independent contractors, as well as the administrative cost of
explaining the benefits and assuring that various other statutory requirements have been met.
Thus, the difference in treatment may provide an incentive for employers to misclassify
employees as independent contractors. Employees may also prefer to be misclassified as
independent contractors in order to avoid coverage under these laws, if they are not willing to
pay the indirect cost for the specific protection provided.
B. Differences Favoring Employee Status
The Social Security, Medicare, and income tax provisions of the Code may, on the other
hand, favor classification as an employee in cases where an individual prefers to receive some
of her compensation in the form of fringe benefits rather than cash. This is because, under the
Code, an employer may provide fringe benefits, such as pensions, accident and health and
group-term life insurance, on a tax-favored basis to its employees but not to its independent
contractors. Such benefits are generally excluded from employees' gross incomes subject to
income tax as well as wages subject to Social Security and Medicare taxes. While independent
contractors can generally establish their own fringe benefit plans, amounts used to purchase such
benefits generally cannot be deducted or excluded from gross income subject to income tax, or
from compensation subject to Social Security and Medicare taxes. Limited exceptions are
provided for certain of the most significant benefits, including pensions and accident and health
insurance; amounts used to purchase these benefits can to some extent be deducted or excluded
from gross income subject to income tax by independent contractors, although they cannot be
deducted or excluded from compensation subject to Social Security and Medicare taxes.
An employer may be reluctant to allow an independent contractor to participate in a plan
as an employee, however, since that might involve additional costs to the employer. This is
particularly true if the independent contractor is highly compensated, in which case her
participation might require the employer to provide additional benefits to its non-highly
compensated employees under the minimum coverage and nondiscrimination requirements of the
Code. Also, short-service independent contractors may not derive any significant benefits from
participation, and may therefore prefer to receive additional cash compensation, instead.
15
The various differences in tax treatment between employees and independent contractors
discussed above are summarized in Table 2-1.
C. Five Hypothetical Examples of Differential Tax Treatment
The preceding discussion indicates that Federal and State tax, labor and related laws do
not systematically favor classification of an individual as an employee or independent contractor.
The most beneficial classification for a particular individual depends instead on her circumstanc-
es, preferences, and negotiating skills. This section illustrates the effects of these differences
using five hypothetical examples.
Each example begins with $1,000 which an employer or service-recipient could spend
on worker compensation. In the employee situation, most of the $1,000 is used to pay the
employee her normal salary plus holiday, vacation and sick pay. The remainder is used to pay
employment taxes (including Social Security and Medicare taxes, and State and Federal
unemployment insurance taxes) and to provide statutorily-required or voluntarily-provided fringe
benefits (including contributions to retirement plans, health insurance premiums, and workers'
compensation premiums). The employee pays any Federal and State income taxes and the
employee share of the Social Security and Medicare taxes due on her salary, and also pays any
work-related expenses (for tools, etc.).^
In the independent contractor situation, the $1,000 spent for worker compensation by the
client is generally assumed to be paid to the independent contractor, although, depending on the
knowledge and relative negotiating skills of the two parties, some might be retained by the
client. The amount, if any, retained by the client is assumed to pass directly to the client's
"bottom line" and, therefore, to be subject to Federal and State corporate income taxes.
In order to maintain the comparison between the employee and the independent
contractor, the independent contractor is assumed to incur the same costs as the employee
(although the tax treatment may be different) and is assumed to purchase directly the same
^ Since the examples show the impact of additional income to the employee or independent
contractor, a 28 percent Federal income tax rate and a 7.5 percent State income tax rate are
assumed to apply to the additional taxable income. The assumed Federal corporate income tax
rate is 34 percent, and the assumed State rate is eight percent. The various tax rates are based
on those that would be paid by or for a middle-income worker.
Table 2-1
M^or Differences in Treatment of Employees and Independent Contractors
for Federal Tax and Other Purposes
Employees
Value of many employer-provided fringe benefits
excluded from income and employment tax bases
Independent Contractors
Fringe Benefits'
Qualified retirement plan contributions excluded from
income but not self-employment tax base
25 percent of health insurance costs deducted from
income but not self-employment tax base
Few other fringe benefits excluded from income or
self-employment tax bases
Trade or Business Expenses
May be deducted from income tax base only by itemizers
and only to the extent expenses exceed two percent of
adjusted gross income
May not be excluded from employment tax base
Certain expenses subject to additional business purpose
requirements
May be deducted from income tax base
May be excluded from self-employment tax base
Administrative Costs
Withholding involves more administrative costs for
employer but less for employee
Estimated tax system involves more administrative
costs for independent contractor but less for client
Estimated tax system allows modest delay in tax
payments relative to withholding
Compliance
Somewhat more ability to be noncompliant due to lack
of withholding, larger trade or business expenses, and
somewhat more limited business purpose requirements
with respect to such expenses
Non-Tax Differences'
Less flexibility in choosing among fringe benefits; value
of employer contributions to retirement plan may be lost
if worker changes jobs frequently
Administrative (and other) costs associated with Federal
and State laws applicable to employees, e.g., minimum
wage
May be unable to obtain fringe benefits, including
statutory fringe benefits such as unemployment
insurance and workers' compensation
May be unable to negotiate worker protections such as
minimum wage and overtime
Dcpartmctit ot the Tre«5ury
Office of T«x Pobcy
1. For a detailed comparison of the tax treatment of fringe benefits and business expenses, see Appendix A. Employer-
provided fringe benefits may be subject to nondiscrimination requirements and other limits.
Some of the non-tax differences, such as minimum wage laws, may be more applicable to less advantaged workers than
to occupations covered by section 1706.
17
benefits that the employee would receive as employer-paid fringe benefits." It is further
assumed that the independent contractor can purchase these benefits at the same cost an employer
could when purchasing for all of its employees as a group/
Example 1--Typical Mix of Fringe Benefits. Example 1 (Table 2-2) shows a situation
in which an employee receives a typical mix of fringe benefits but does not incur any deductible
trade or business expenses. The employer pays the employer share of Social Security and
Medicare taxes, as well as the total cost of workers' compensation premiums and Federal and
State unemployment insurance taxes. The employer also makes contributions to retirement and
medical insurance plans for the employee, each costing six percent of total compensation. The
employee receives regular, vacation, holiday and sick pay of $806, out of which the employee's
share of Social Security and Medicare taxes, as well as Federal and State income taxes, are paid.
The independent contractor receives the entire $1,000 in cash. Out of that, she pays Federal and
State income taxes. Social Security and Medicare taxes, buys health insurance, and contributes
to a tax-favored "Keogh" retirement plan. As shown in Table 2-2, the independent contractor
pays $12 more in Federal income tax, $4 more in State income tax, and $18 more in Social
Security and Medicare tax.
Taxes are higher for the independent contractor in Example 1 because the part of her
cash income that was used to provide fringe benefits in the case of the employee is subject to
Social Security and Medicare taxes, and some is also subject to income taxes. Current Federal
law attempts to equate the tax rate for employees and self-employed persons for Social Security
and Medicare tax purposes. Nevertheless, there are differences in the tax base. Self-employed
persons may not exclude the value of fringe benefits they purchase for themselves from the
Social Security and Medicare tax base (other than the employer portion of Social Security and
Medicare taxes), while the value of employer-provided fringe benefits is typically excluded from
that base in the case of employees. Hence, in Example 1, the Social Security tax is $18, or 15
percent, higher for the independent contractor than for the employee. The income tax system
does provide deductions for self-employed persons for contributions to retirement plans (and for
the equivalent to the employer portion of Social Security and Medicare taxes), but it only
* In practice, the lower after-tax price for voluntarily-provided fringe benefits would likely
result in greater expenditures for these items in the employee case. Conversely, the lower after-
tax price of certain trade or business expenses for independent contractors would likely result
in higher trade or business expenses for such individuals.
' This assumption is made for simplicity and may be approximately correct for small
employers. For large employers, economies of scale are probably important.
Table 2-2
EXAMPLE 1: COMPARISON OF INCOME AND TAXATION OF $1,000 OF TOTAL COMPENSATION
FOR AN EMPLOYEE OR INDEPENDENT CONTRACTOR,
WORKER WITH A TYPICAL MIX OF FRINGE BENEFITS AND NO WORKER EXPENSES
Employer/Employee
Employer Employee Combined
Independent Contractor
Service
Recipient Worker Combined
Money Payment or Regular Salary 733 733 1,000 1,000
HolidayA^acation/Sick Pay 73 73
MONEY PAYMENT OR TOTAL SALARY 806 806~ 1,000 1,000
Employer-Paid Taxes and Benefits 194 194
TOTAL COMPENSATION TO WORKER 1.000 1,000
Retained by Service Recipient 0
TOTAL COMPENSATION 1,000 1,000
TAXES AND STATUTORY BENEFITS, TOTAL 74 331 405 0 427 427
Federal Income Tax 1/2/ 209 209 0 221 221
State Income Tax 1/3/ 60 60 0 64 64
Social Security (FICA/SECA) 4/ 62 62 123 141 141
Unemployment Insurance (FUTA and State) 5/4 4
Workers' Compensation 6/ 8 8
VOLUNTARY FRINGE BENEFITS, TOTAL 120 0 120 0 120 120
Retirement/Keogh Contribution 60 60 60 60
Health Insurance Premiums 60 60 60 60
WORKER EXPENSES (DEDUCTIBLE), TOTAL 0 0 0
Income and Social Security Tax Compliance Rate 100.0% 100.0%
For Worker
Total Compensation less
Taxes and Statutory Benefits 595 573
Money Income less
Worker Taxes 475 573
Money Income less Worker Taxes,
Worker-Paid Benefits, and Worker Expenses 475 453
For Employer (Service Recipient)
Retained by Service Recipient less Taxes 0 0
Department of the Treasury
Office of Tax Analysis
Note: Detail may not add to totals due to rounding.
1/ Taxable amount is money payment to the worker less deductions consistent with worker status. Employee has itemized deductions
for state income taxes (for federal tax purposes but not for state tax purposes) and for worker expenses in excess of 2 percent of
adjusted gross income (assumed to be 4 percent of money payment). Independent contractor deducts worker expenses, Keogh
contributions, 25 percent of health insurance premium, and 50 percent of SEC A tax.
2/ 28 percent rate for the worker, and 34 percent rate for the service recipient.
3/ 7.5 percent rate for the worker, and 8 percent rate for the service recipient.
4/ 7.65 percent rate for the employee and for the employer, or 14.12955 percent rate ([100%-7.65%]xl5.3%) paid entirely by the
independent contractor.
5/ Assumed to be 0.55 percent of total salary.
6/ Assumed to be I percent of total salary.
19
permits a deduction for 25 percent of medical insurance costs (and then only in some
circumstances), and it does not permit a deduction for the cash equivalent of other fringe
benefits, which in this example only consist of the costs of unemployment insurance and
workers' compensation.
Example 2-Noncompliance. Independent contractors may have greater opportunity than
employees to be less than fully compliant with tax laws. Employees are subject to withholding,
and the amount of their wage income is reported with great precision to the IRS. Independent
contractors may be able to omit some of their income on their tax returns, although that becomes
more difficult when their gross income is reported to IRS on information returns (generally
Forms 1099-MISC). Even if independent contractors report 100 percent of their income,
however, they may be able to lower their reported tax liability by overstating expenses. Since
the workers in Example 2 do not have trade or business expenses, the noncompliance consists
solely of the failure to report all of gross income. Example 2 (Table 2-3) illustrates the effect
of a lower compliance rate on the independent contractor's tax liabilities. Example 2 is the same
as Example 1 , except that the independent contractor is assumed to report only 95 percent of her
net income from self-employment. As a result of this underreporting by five percent, the
independent contractor's Federal and State income taxes are now virtually the same as for the
employee, although the Social Security tax is still $11, or nine percent, higher.* At greater
levels of noncompliance, the taxes of the independent contractors would be lower than those of
the fully compliant employee.^
Example 3-Trade or Business Expenses. Employee business expenses can also
differentially affect the tax treatment of employees and independent contractors. Example 3
(Table 2-4) is similar to Example 1, except that the worker is now assumed to have expenses
equivalent to ten percent of total compensation. The independent contractor is able to deduct all
of these expenses in calculating income subject to both income and Social Security and Medicare
taxes. In contrast, the employee's Social Security and Medicare taxes are not adjusted at all to
reflect these expenses. For income tax purposes, these expenses may be reflected if the worker
itemizes deductions on her income tax return, but, even then, they are only deductible to the
extent that they, together with other miscellaneous deductions, exceed two percent of her
* See Table 5-3 for a summary of the compliance rates found in one recent IRS study.
"^ See Table 5-2 for a summary of compliance rates actually found in one IRS study. For
technical services workers in that study, reporting of gross receipts was 97.0 percent, and
reporting of net income {i.e., gross receipts minus business expenses) was 83.4 percent.
Table 2-3
EXAMPLE 2: COMPARISON OF INCOME AND TAXATION OF $1,000 OF TOTAL COMPENSATION
FOR AN EMPLOYEE OR INDEPENDENT CONTRACTOR.
WORKER WITH A TYPICAL MIX OF FRINGE BENEFITS, NO WORKER EXPENSES,
AND 5 PERCENT NON-COMPLIANCE BY THE INDEPENDENT CONTRACTOR
Employer/Employee
Employer Employee Combined
Independent Contractor
Service
Recipient Worker Combined
Money Payment or Regular Salary 733 733 1,000 1.000
Holiday/Vacation/Sick Pay 73 73
MONEY PAYMENT OR TOTAL SALARY io6 156" 1,000 1,000
Employer-Paid Taxes and BeneFits
TOTAL COMPENSATION TO WORKER 1.000 1,000
Retained by Service Recipient
TOTAL COMPENSATION 1,000 1.000
TAXES AND STATUTORY BENEFITS. TOTAL 74 331 405 0 404 404
Federal Income Tax 1/ 2/ 209 209 0 209 209
Sute Income Tax 1/3/ 60 60 0 61 61
Social Security (FICA/SECA) 4/ 62 62 123 134 134
Unemployment Insurance (FUTA and State) SI 4 4
Workers' Compensation 6/ 8 8
VOLUNTARY FRINGE BENEFITS. TOTAL 120 0 120 0 120 120
Retirement/Keogh Contribution 60 60 60 60
Health Insurance Premiums 60 60 60 60
WORKER EXPENSES (DEDUCTIBLE), TOTAL 0 0 0 0
Income and Social Security Tax Compliance Rate 100.0% 95.0%
For Worker
Total Compensation less
Taxes and Statutory Benefits 595 596
Money Income less
Worker Taxes 475 596
Money Income less Worker Taxes,
Worker-Paid Benefits, and Worker Expenses 475 476
For Employer (Service Recipient)
Retained by Service Recipient less taxes 0 0
Department of the Treasury
Office of Tax Analysis
Note: Detail may not add to totals due to rounding.
1/ Taxable amount is money payment to the worker less deductions consistent with worker status. Employee has itemized deductions
for state income taxes (for federal tax purposes but not for state tax purposes) and for worker expenses in excess of 2 percent of
adjusted gross income (assumed to be 4 percent of money payment). Independent contractor deducts worker expenses, Keogli
contributions, 25 percent of health insurance premium, and 50 percent of SECA tax.
2/ 28 percent rate for the worker, and 34 percent rate for the service recipient.
3/ 7.5 percent rate for the worker, and 8 percent rate for the service recipient.
4/ 7.65 percent rate for the employee and for the employer, or 14. 12955 percent rate ([100%-7.65%]xl5.3%) paid entirely by the
independent contractor.
5/ Assumed to be 0.55 percent of total salary.
6/ Assumed to be 1 percent of total salary.
Table 2-4
EXAMPLE 3: COMPARISON OF INCOME AND TAXATION OF $1,000 OF TOTAL COMPENSATION
FOR AN EMPLOYEE OR INDEPENDENT CONTRACTOR,
WORKER WFTH A TYPICAL MIX OF FRINGE BENEFITS
AND WORKER EXPENSES OF 10 PERCENT
Employer/Employee
Employer Employee Combined
Independent Contractor
Service
Recipient Worker Combined
Money Payment or Regular Salary 733 733 1,000 1,000
Holiday/Vacation/Sick Pay 73 73_
MONEY PAYMENT OR TOTAL SALARY 806 806 1,000 1,000
Employer-Paid Taxes and Benefits 194 194
TOTAL COMPENSATION TO WORKER 1.000 1,000
Retained by Service Recipient 0
TOTAL COMPENSATION 1,000 1,000
TAXES AND STATUTORY BENEFITS, TOTAL 74 308 382 0 381 381
Federal Income Tax 1/ 2/ 191 191 0 197 197
State Income Tax 1/3/ 55 55 0 57 57
Social Security (FICA/SECA) 4/ 62 62 123 127 127
Unemployment Insurance (FUTA and State) 5/ 4 4
Workers' Compensation 6/ 8 8
VOLUNTARY FRINGE BENEFITS, TOTAL 120 0 120 0 120 120
Retirement/Keogh Contribution 60 60 60 60
Health Insurance Premiums 60 60 60 60
WORKER EXPENSES (DEDUCTIBLE). TOTAL 0 100 100 0 .100 100
Income and Social Security Tax Compliance Rate 100.0% 100.09!
For Worker
Total Compensation less
Taxes and Statutory Benefits 618 619
Money Income less
Worker Taxes 498 619
Money Income less Worker Taxes,
Worker-Paid Benefits , and Worker Expenses 398 399
For Employer (Service Recipient)
Retained by Service Recipient less Taxes 0 0
Department of the Treasury
Office of Tax Analysis
Note: Detail may not add to totals due to rounding.
1/ Taxable amount is money payment to the worker less deductions consistent with worker status. Employee has itemized deductions
for state income taxes (for federal tax purposes but not for state tax purposes) and for worker expenses in excess of 2 percent of
adjusted gross income (assumed to be 4 percent of money payment). Independent contractor deducts worker expenses, Keogli
contributions, 25 percent of health insurance premium, and 50 percent of SECA tax.
2/ 28 jjercent rate for the worker, and 34 percent rate for the service recipient.
3/ 7.5 percent rate for the worker, and 8 percent rate for the service recipient.
4/ 7.65 percent rate for the employee and for the employer, or 14. 12955 percent rate ([100%-7.65%]xl5.3%) paid entirely by the
independent contractor.
5/ Assumed to be 0.55 percent of total salary.
6/ Assumed to be 1 percent of total salary.
22
adjusted gross income from all sources. In Example 3, it is assumed that the effective deduction
floor is equivalent to four percent of total compensation, so that only the excess over that level
is deductible. As a result of the differential treatment of these trade or business expenses, the
extra Federal income tax paid by the independent contractor has been reduced from $12 to $6,
and the extra State income tax has been reduced from $4 to $2. The extra Social Security tax
has been reduced from $18 to $4, however.
Effect of Expenses on Noncompliance Rates. The noncompliance rate for net income
generally does not equal the noncompliance rate for gross income. The rates are equal only
when gross income and net income are equal because the worker has no trade or business
expenses. When the worker has such expenses, the noncompliance rate for net income exceeds
the noncompliance rate for gross income. The higher the level of expenses, the greater the
difference between noncompliance rates becomes. Consider a worker with gross income of
$1,000 and expenses of $400; net income is $600. If the worker understates gross income by
ten percent, net income will be understated by 16.7 percent.*
The noncompliance rate for net income and the difference between the gross and net
income compliance rates will be greater if the worker can use the existence of trade or business
expenses to understate net income further by overstating expenses. In the example above, if the
worker both understates gross income by ten percent and overstates expenses by ten percent, net
income will be understated by 23.3 percent.'
Example 4-Statutorily-Required Fringe Benefits Only. In Example 4 (Table 2-5), the
employer is assumed not to provide any voluntary fringe benefits. In addition to salary, the
employer pays only for the employer portion of Social Security and Medicare taxes, the Federal
and State unemployment taxes, and workers' compensation insurance premiums. Since fringe
benefits, which cause the disparity between Social Security and Medicare tax levels for
employees and independent contractors, have been greatly reduced, there is only a $1 difference
in Social Security and Medicare taxes between the employee and the independent contractor.
The additional Federal income tax paid by the independent contractor is $4, and the additional
* Net and gross income are both understated by $100. The noncompliance rate on gross
income is $100/$1,000; the noncompliance rate on net income is $100/$600.
' Gross income is understated by $100. Expenses are overstated by ten percent, or $40.
Net income is understated by $140. The noncompliance rate on net income is $140/$600.
Table 2-5
EXAMPLE 4: COMPARISON OF INCOME AND TAXATION OF $1,000 OF TOTAL COMPENSATION
FOR EMPLOYEE OR INDEPENDENT CONTRACTOR.
WORKER WITH ONLY STATUTORY BENEFITS AND NO WORKER EXPENSES
Employer/Employee
Independent Contractor
Service
Employer Employee Combined Recipient Worker Combined
Money Payment or Regular Salary 916 916 1.000 1,000
HolidayA'acation/Sick Pay 0
MONEY PAYMENT OR TOTAL SALARY 916 916 1,000 1.000
Employer-Paid Taxes and Benefits 84 84
TOTAL COMPENSATION TO WORKER 1.000 1,000
Retained by Service Recipient 2
TOTAL COMPENSATION 1.000 1,000
TAXES AND STATUTORY BENEFITS, TOTAL 84 376 460 0 452 452
Federal Income Tax 1/ 2/ 237 237 0 241 241
State Income Tax 1/3/ 69 69 0 70 70
Social Security (FICA/SECA) 4/ 70 70 140 141 141
Unemployment Insurance (FUTA and State) 5/ 5 5
Workers' Compensation 6/ 9 9
VOLUNTARY FRINGE BENEFITS, TOTAL 0 0 0 0
Retirement/Keogh Contribution 0 0
Health Insurance Premiums 0 0
WORKER EXPENSES (DEDUCTIBLE), TOTAL 0 0 0 0
Income and Social Security Tax Compliance Rate 100.0% 100.0%
For Worker
Total Compensation less
Taxes and Statutory Benefits 540 548
Money Income less
Worker Taxes 540 548
Money Income less Worker Taxes,
Worker-Paid BenefiU, and Worker Expenses 540 548
For Employer (Service Recipient)
Retained by Service Recipient less Taxes 0 0
Department of the Treasury
Office of Tax Analysis
Note: Detail may not add to totals due to rounding.
1/ Taxable amount is money payment to the worker less deductions consistent with worker status. Employee has itemized deductions
for state income taxes (for federal tax purposes but not for state tax purposes) and for worker expenses in excess of 2 percent of
adjusted gross income (assumed to be 4 percent of money payment). Independent contractor deducts worker expenses, Keogh
contributions, 25 percent of health insurance premium, and 50 percent of SECA tax.
2/ 28 percent rate for the worker, and 34 percent rate for the service recipient.
3/ 7.5 percent rate for the worker, and 8 percent rate for the service recipient.
4/ 7.65 percent rate for the employee and for the employer, or 14. 12955 percent rate ([100%-7.65%]xl5.3%) paid entirely by the
independent contractor.
5/ Assumed to be 0.55 percent of total salary.
6/ Assumed to be 1 percent of total salary.
24
State income tax is $1. The situation illustrated in Example 4 is typical of many temporary
employees, whose fringe benefits are often restricted to those required by law.'°
Note that in Example 4, as a result of higher cash wages exactly offsetting the reduction
in fringe benefits, both workers' total current tax bills have increased compared with the workers
in Example 1. For the employee, the sum of the Federal and State income taxes and the
combined employer-employee Social Security and Medicare taxes has increased by $53, or 13
percent. For the independent contractor, the combined bill has increased by $25, or six percent.
Example 5-Lower Independent Contractor Compensation. Example 5 (Table 2-6) is
similar to Example 4, except that the independent contractor's compensation is slightly lower
because she has been unable to negotiate from her client the equivalent of the value of the
employer's costs for workers' compensation and unemployment insurance (i.e., her bargaining
power is lower than in Example 4). Since this wedge between total employee compensation and
total payments to the independent contractor is small, the resulting tax differences are also small.
Because the independent contractor now has less income, her Social Security and Medicare taxes
are now slightly lower ($1) than those paid by the employer and the employee. Also, the
independent contractor's Federal and State income taxes are now the same as those of the
employee. However, because the client must pay income tax on the funds it has retained, the
combined income taxes of the independent contractor and her client are still $6, or two percent,
higher than those of the employee."
Summary. These examples illustrate that the difference in income. Social Security and
Medicare taxes paid by employers and employees, on the one hand, and independent contractors
and their clients, on the other, on the same amount of total compensation depends on the
proportion of compensation the individual takes as fringe benefits, the extent of the individual's
work-related expenses, and the relative compliance of employees and independent contractors.
With typical patterns of fringe benefits and worker expenses, independent contractors and their
clients tend to pay higher levels of taxes, especially Social Security and Medicare taxes, than
'° U.S. Department of Labor, Bureau of Labor Statistics, BLS Reports on its First Survey
of Pay and Employee Benefits in the Temporary Help Supply Industry, 88-260, page 8 (1988).
" Employees with substantial trade or business expenses and sufficient bargaining power
may be able to negotiate with their employers to structure computer and auto expenses as
required business expenses. In such a situation, the worker would still be subject to the two-
percent floor, but would be able to deduct expenses that would normally not be deductible.
Table 2-6
EXAMPLE 5: COMPARISON OF INCOME AND TAXATION OF SI .000 OF TOTAL COMPENSATION
FOR EMPLOYEE OR INDEPENDENT CONTRACTOR,
WORKER WITH ONLY STATUTORY BENEFITS. NO WORKER EXPENSES.
AND A "WEDGE" BETWEEN EMPLOYEE AND INDEPENDENT CONTRACTOR TOTAL COMPENSATION
Employer/Employee
Employer Employee Combined
Independent Contractor
Service
Recipient Worker Combined
Money Payment or Regular Salary 916 916 986 986
Holiday/Vacation/Sick Pay 0
MONEY PAYMENT OR TOTAL SALARY 916 916 986 986
Employer-Paid Taxes and BeneHts 84 84
TOTAL COMPENSATION TO WORKER 1,000 986
Retained by Service Recipient 14 14
TOTAL COMPENSATION 1,000 1,000
TAXES AND STATUTORY BENEFITS, TOTAL 84 376 460 6 445 451
Federal Income Tax 1/2/ 237 237 4 237 242
State Income Tax 1/3/ 69 69 1 69 70
Social Security (FICA/SECA) 4/ 70 70 140 139 139
Unemployment Insurance (FUTA and State) 5/ 5 5
Workers' Compensation 6/ 9 9
VOLUNTARY FRINGE BENEFITS, TOTAL 0 0 0 0
Retirement/Keogh Contribution 0 0
Health Insurance Premiums 0 0
WORKER EXPENSES (DEDUCTIBLE), TOTAL 0 0 0 0
Income and Social Security Tax Compliance Rate 100.0% 100.0%
For Worker
Total Compensation less
Taxes and Statutory Benefits 540 541
Money Income less
Worker Taxes 540 541
Money Income less Worker Taxes,
Worker-Paid Benefits , and Worker Expenses 540 54 1
For Employer (Service Recipient)
Retained by Service Recipient less Taxes 0 9
Department of the Treasury
Office of Tax Analysis
Note: Detail may not add to totals due to rounding.
1/ Taxable amount is money payment to the worker less deductions consistent with worker status. Employee has itemized deductions
for state income taxes (for federal tax purposes but not for state tax purposes) and for worker expenses in excess of 2 percent of
adjusted gross income (assumed to be 4 percent of money payment). Independent contractor deducts worker expenses, Keogh
contributions, 25 percent of health insurance premium, and 50 percent of SECA tax.
2/ 28 percent rate for the worker, and 34 percent rate for the service recipient.
3/ 7.5 percent rate for the worker, and 8 percent rate for the service recipient.
4/ 7.65 percent rate for the employee and for the employer, or 14. 12955 percent rate ([100%-7.65%]xl5.3%) paid entirely by the
independent contractor.
5/ Assumed to be 0.55 percent of total salary.
6/ Assumed to be 1 percent of total salary.
26
employees and employers, provided that the income and expenses are reported correctly.'^
When independent contractors receive few fringe benefits that are not statutorily-required (as is
typical for temporary workers), however, and have few or no trade or business expenses, they
and their clients may pay about the same level of taxes as employees and employers, provided
that the income and expenses are reported correctly.
D. Validity of Differences
It is evident from the preceding discussion that a mere change in classification of an
individual as an employee or independent contractor can result in differences in the total tax
liability of the individual and the service-recipient, regardless of whether there has been any
change in their economic circumstances. While such differences may seem arbitrary or unfair
in the case of individuals whose relationship with a service-recipient places them close to the line
between employee and independent contractor status, these differences can generally be justified
for more "typical" employees and independent contractors. For example, withholding, the
partial disallowance of trade or business expense deductions, and the imposition of additional
business purpose requirements on those deductions, may be more administratively appropriate
for employees than independent contractors, on the assumption that independent contractors
typically have more volatile net incomes and larger trade or business expenses, and typically
change jobs more frequently than employees. Similarly, the special treatment accorded to
employee fringe benefits under the Code, and the special protections for employees found in
Federal and State labor laws, may be justified if employees typically have less bargaining power
than independent contractors and are more dependent on a single business for their livelihoods.
Even if these assumptions regarding "typical" employees and independent contractors are
correct, the fact that a single broad distinction is drawn under the Code between employees and
independent contractors means that some "atypical" individuals may not be treated properly.
For example, withholding and the partial disallowance of trade or business expense deductions
may not be appropriate (except as a compliance measure) for an employee who regularly incurs
large expenses and changes jobs frequently: in such situations it might be preferable to treat the
individual as an employee for one purpose and an independent contractor for another. Similarly,
independent contractors who lack significant bargaining power or financial sophistication may
be better off being treated as employees under the fringe benefit provisions of the Code and
under Federal and State labor laws. Nevertheless, the costs of such inappropriate results in
'^ The higher levels of Social Security taxes may in some cases result in a comparable
increase in Social Security benefits.
27
some cases must be balanced against the benefits of maintaining a single standard that applies
for all purposes.
Of course, it may be that these assumptions regarding the characteristics of "typical"
employees and independent contractors are not generally correct. If this is the case, and the
current scheme therefore results in inappropriate results in too many cases, it may be desirable
to develop new definitions of employee or even to reexamine the need for the current-law
distinctions between employees and independent contractors. For example, if most independent
contractors lack the means or the foresight to provide for their own retirement income or health
insurance coverage, there may be no reason to limit the fringe benefit provisions of the Code
to employees, except perhaps in the case of wealthier or more sophisticated individuals.
Similarly, there may be no reason for the differences in treatment of employees and independent
contractors with respect to the excludability of fringe benefits from the Social Security and
Medicare tax base, which arose at a time when fringe benefits made up only a small portion of
total income.
CHAPTER 3: ORIGINS OF SECTION 1706
I. SECTION 530
In the late 1960s, the IRS began to increase its employment tax enforcement activities,
which had previously been sporadic, to address the misclassification of employees as independent
contractors. Since, as noted above, independent contractors and their clients at that time faced
significantly lower Social Security and Medicare tax rates than employers and employees, such
misclassification was perceived to produce large revenue losses. As a result of the IRS' action,
the number of reclassifications increased substantially." Many of these reclassifications
resulted in large assessments against the employers involved for employer Social Security,
Medicare, and Federal unemployment insurance taxes, and unwithheld employee Social Security,
Medicare, and income taxes.
Taxpayers complained to Congress that the reclassifications amounted to a change of
position by the IRS in how it was applying the common law tests for determining an individual's
status as an employee or an independent contractor."* House and Senate conferees reporting
on the Tax Reform Act of 1976 urged the IRS "not to apply any changed position or any newly
stated position which is inconsistent with a prior general audit position in this general area to
past, as opposed to future[,] taxable years" until the completion of a study by the Joint
Committee on Taxation on the independent contractor issue."
The Joint Committee asked the General Accounting Office (GAG) to examine the IRS
administration of employment taxes. This study was completed by the GAO in 1977."^ The
study recommended that a safe harbor test of independent contractor status dealing with
situations where an individual carries her own trade or business be added to Code, and that
" See IRS Annual Reports for 1971-1978.
'* See Staff of the Joint Committee on Taxation, 96th Cong., 1st Sess., General Explanation
of the Revenue Act of 1978, 300-01 (Comm. Print 1979); H.R. Conf. Rep. No. 1800, 95th
Cong., 2d Sess. 271 (1978); H.R. Rep. No. 1748, 95th Cong., 2d Sess. 5-6 (1978); S. Rep.
No. 938, 94th Cong., 2d Sess. 604 (1976).
" H.R. Conf. Rep. No. 1515, 94th Cong., 2d Sess. 489 (1976).
'* GAO, Tax Treatment of Employees and Self-Employed Persons by the Internal Revenue
Service: Problems and Solutions, GGD-77-88 (1977).
29
30
certain other changes be made to reduce the financial burden of retroactive employment tax
assessments. The study also found that employees misclajsified as independent contractors on
average reported 96 percent of their wages. This finding, however, was based on payments by
a sample of only five employers involved in employment tax audits.*^ Noting limitations in
the GAO sample, the IRS undertook its own study. Based on payments by a sample of 2,600
employers to 7,109 individuals that it had previously proposed to reclassify as wages, the IRS
found an average income tax reporting compliance rate of 76.2 percent and an average
employment tax reporting compliance rate of 70.0 percent.'* It also found that compliance
rates varied less by industry than by the size of payment and other factors, with small payments
and those likely to have been made in cash much less likely to be reported.
In the Revenue Act of 1978, Congress, without mentioning the GAO study, provided
statutory relief for certain taxpayers involved in employment tax controversies with the IRS.
Section 530 of the Act prohibits the IRS from challenging an employer's treatment of an
individual as an independent contractor for employment tax purposes if the employer (1) has a
reasonable basis for such treatment and (2) consistently treats the individual, and any other
individual holding a substantially similar position, as an independent contractor.'' Section 530
does not merely provide relief from retroactive assessments: as long as these requirements are
met with respect to an individual, the IRS is prevented from correcting an erroneous
classification of that individual. Section 530 applies solely for purposes of the employment tax
provisions of the Code (e.g.. Social Security, Medicare, unemployment insurance taxes, and
income tax withholding). It does not affect an individual's classification as an employee for
income tax purposes; treatment of an individual as an employee for income tax purposes may,
however, violate the consistency requirement noted above and thereby cause the employer to lose
25.
" Id. at 25 and 71. A larger sample showed compliance rates of only 87 percent. Id. at
18
See id.. Appendix V; Hearings Before the Subcommittee on Select Revenue Measures
of the House Ways and Means Committee, 96th Cong., 1st Sess. (June 20, 1979) (Statement of
Donald C. Lubick, Assistant Secretary of the Treasury (Tax Policy)).
'' Revenue Act of 1978, Pub. L. No. 95-600, § 530, 92 Stat. 2763, 2885 (1978). These
requirements must be met before the commencement of any IRS compliance procedures with
respect to an individual. Rev. Proc. 85-18, § 3.03(C), 1985-1 C.B. 518.
31
protection under section 530. Section 530 treats reasonable reliance on any of the following as
a reasonable basis for treating an individual as an independent contractor:
(1) judicial precedent, published rulings, or letter rulings or technical advice memoranda
issued to or with respect to the taxpayer;
(2) a past IRS audit in which there was no assessment attributable to the employment tax
treatment of the individual or of individuals holding positions substantially similar to that
of the individual; or
(3) a long-standing recognized practice of a significant segment of the industry in which the
individual was engaged.
The IRS has issued a series of revenue procedures since 1978 explaining the application of
section 530.^°
Section 530 was originally described as an interim measure to provide relief until
"Congress ha[d] adequate time to resolve the many complex issues involved in this area",^' and
was scheduled to expire after 1979. It was instead extended through a series of public laws, and
was made permanent in the Tax Equity and Fiscal Responsibility Act of 1982 (TEFRA).^^
n. SECTION 3509
In TEFRA, Congress added section 3509 to the Code to mitigate the problem of large
retroactive employment tax assessments faced by employers who were not entitled to relief under
section 530." Under prior law, in the event of a misclassification an employer could be held
liable for the full amount of unwithheld income taxes and the unwithheld employee share of
Social Security and Medicare taxes. In addition, the employer remained liable for Federal
unemployment insurance tax and the employer share of Social Security and Medicare taxes.
^° Rev. Proc. 78-35, 1978-2 C.B. 536, was issued soon after enactment. The current
version is Rev. Proc. 85-18, 1985-1 C.B. 518.
^' Staff of the Joint Committee on Taxation, 96th Cong., 1st Sess., General Explanation
of the Revenue Act of 1978, 300-01 (Comm. Print 1979).
22 Pub. L. No. 96-167, § 9(d), 93 Stat. 1275, 1278 (1979); Pub. L. No. 96-541, § 1, 94
Stat. 3204 (1980); Pub. L. No. 97-248, § 269(c), 96 Stat. 325, 552-53 (1982).
^ Pub. L. No. 97-248, § 270(a), 96 Stat. 325, 553 (1982).
32
Penalties and interest could also be assessed. The employer bore the burden of proving that the
employee had paid income and Social Security and Medicare taxes on the wages in order to
abate any liability.^
Section 3509 generally limits an employer's liability for failure to withhold income,
Social Security or Medicare taxes on payments made to an individual whom it misclassified as
an independent contractor to 1.5 percent of the wages paid to the individual plus 20 percent of
the employee portion of Social Security and Medicare taxes on those wages." Section 3509
has no effect on an employer's own liability for Federal unemployment insurance taxes or the
employer portion of Social Security and Medicare taxes; it also does not apply in cases of
intentional disregard of the withholding requirements.^* As a quid pro quo for limiting the
employer's liability for failure to withhold employee taxes, section 3509 prohibits the employer
from reducing its liability by recovering any tax determined under the section from the
employee, and gives the employer no credit for any income taxes ultimately paid the
employee.^
m. SECTION 1706
Section 530 affects different taxpayers differently, depending on whether they satisfy the
conditions for relief contained therein. In particular, some taxpayers that have consistently
misclassified their employees as independent contractors are entitled to relief under section 530,
while other taxpayers in the same industry (that, for example, have sometimes taken more
^ In many cases, the misclassified employee had paid SECA taxes on the wages. The
employer could not require the employee to provide evidence of this payment, however.
" If the employer did not comply with the information reporting requirements associated
with the treatment of an individual as an independent contractor, these percentages are doubled
to 3.0 and 40 percent, respectively.
^* If an employer's liability is determined under section 3509, the employee is liable for the
entire amount of unwithheld Social Security and Medicare taxes, unreduced by any amount paid
by the employer. Rev. Rul. 86-111, 1986-2 C.B. 176.
" Code § 3509(d)(1). In some instances, an employer would be better off under the old
rules, e.g., if it can establish that its workers have paid their income taxes in full despite its
failure to withhold, and therefore have its liability abated. Section 3509 is a mandatory
provision, however.
33
conservative positions on classification issues) are not, because they cannot satisfy the
consistency requirements of the section.
In the mid-1980s, some employers in the technical services industry complained that this
difference in treatment under section 530 created an unfair advantage for certain of their
competitors. According to the staff of the Joint Committee on Taxation,
Congress was informed that many employers in the technical services industry
that did not qualify for relief under section 530 nonetheless had claimed that their
workers were independent contractors, despite the fact that such workers would
be classified as employees under the common-law test. It is further contended
that some of these employers were relying on erroneous interpretations of section
530, while others simply perceived that the IRS would not aggressively enforce
employment tax issues.^*
The dispute was primarily between two groups of taxpayers, both of which were engaged in the
business of arranging for the provision of services by technical services personnel to other
companies. One group (sometimes called "technical service firms") generally treated the
service-providers as their employees, and they argued that the other group (sometimes called
"brokerage firms" or "job-shops") achieved unfair cost savings by treating the service-providers
as independent contractors.^' As explained in Chapter 2, however, misclassification of an
employee as an independent contractor does not necessarily result in any cost savings unless the
misclassification is accompanied by underreporting of income or similar compliance problems
by the independent contractors, or unless the client is able to pay the independent contractor less
than the sum of the cash compensation and fringe benefits it would have paid to an employee.
As a result of these complaints. Congress in TRA 1986 excluded taxpayers that broker
the services of engineers, designers, drafters, computer programmers, systems analysts and
"other similarly skilled workers engaged in a similar line of work" from the safe harbor
2* Staff of the Joint Committee on Taxation, 100th Cong., 1st Sess., General Explanation
of the Tax Reform Act of 1986, 1344 (Comm. Print 1987).
^' The first group is represented in part by two trade associations, ADAPSO and the
National Technical Services Association (NTSA). The second group is represented in part by
the National Association of Computer Consultant Businesses (NACCB).
34
provided by section 530, effective for payments made after December 31, 1986.'*' Section
1706 applies exclusively to multi-party situations, i.e., those involving (1) technical services
workers, (2) a company that uses the workers, and (3) a firm that supplies the workers. The
effect of section 1706 is to deny relief solely to the firm that supplies the workers. Section 1706
did not affect the application of section 3509 to such firms.
Congress may have believed that the denial of section 530 relief to this group of
taxpayers would cause most or all technical services workers to be reclassified as employees.^'
Section 1706 does not, however, actually require that the individuals listed in the provision be
treated as employees: it merely requires them to be classified as employees or independent
contractors for employment tax purposes under the usual common law tests, and permits the IRS
to issue guidance with respect to such classification.'^
Since the enactment of section 1706, the IRS has increased its enforcement activity in the
employment tax area across the board, including the technical services industry. It has also
issued guidance on the proper classification of technical services workers as employees or
independent contractors.''
30
Pub. L. No. 99-514, § 1706, 100 Stat. 2095, 2781 (1986).
" See H.R. Conf. Rep. No. 841, 99th Cong., 2d Sess. 11-834 (1986); 132 Cong. Rec.
S8088-89 (June 20, 1986) (floor Statement by Sen. Moynihan introducing predecessor to section
1706).
'^ Notice 87-19, 1987-1 C.B. 455. As described in footnote 57, however, there was some
initial confusion over this point after the enactment of section 1706.
33
Rev. Rul. 87-41, 1987-1 C.B. 296.
PART THREE
DISCUSSION OF ISSUES
CHAPTER 4: GENERAL POLICY ISSUES
I. OVERVIEW
Differences in treatment between employees and independent contractors under Federal
and State tax and other laws were described in Chapter 2. This chapter addresses the policy
issues underlying these differences in treatment. This report proceeds from the assumption that
the government's basic role is to maintain the efficiency of labor markets by not interfering in
the natural diversity of firm/worker arrangements unless specific policy goals require
intervention. The source of this diversity and its importance to the efficient functioning of labor
markets is discussed in Section II of this chapter. Neutrality in the tax treatment of employees
and independent contractors, addressed in Section HI, in most circumstances is necessary to
maintain the efficiency of labor markets and is required to insure tax equity between the two
groups of workers. These tax policy issues are illustrated using the examples presented in
Chapter 2. An additional goal of tax policy, addressed in Section IV, is to minimize tax
compliance costs for firms, workers, and tax administration agencies while maximizing taxpayer
compliance. Finally, the non-tax policies of the Federal and State governments affecting labor
markets are described in Section V.
n. EFFICIENCY OF LABOR MARKETS
Well-functioning labor markets have a diversity of arrangements between workers and
firms. The diversity arises naturally from differences in workers' skills and preferences and
differences in firms' organizations and production processes. Workers search out firms that
offer arrangements that best match the worker's skills and preferences. Likewise, firms search
out workers whose skills and preferences best match the firms' needs. Searching by workers
and firms is accomplished through labor markets, which may be informal or well organized.
However organized, the more efficiently labor markets work— that is, the more closely workers'
skills and preferences are matched to firms' needs-the greater will be workers' real income and
firms' productivity.
A. Arrangements Between Workers and Firms
Workers' Skills and Preferences. The significant differences in the level and range of
workers' skills are important determinants of the occupations and industries that workers enter,
as well as the particular firms for which they choose to work. There are also significant
differences in preferences across workers. For example, some workers prefer a stable
37
38
relationship with a firm, with a low risk of being laid off, while other workers prefer greater
variety in their work or greater autonomy over their work, than could normally be provided by
a single employer. Other things being the same, workers with the first set of preferences are
more likely to enter long-term employer/employee arrangements with firms. Workers with the
second set of preferences, in contrast, are more likely to work as independent contractors for
a number of firms (service-recipients), perhaps working for none of the firms for any extended
period of time, and perhaps working for more than one simultaneously. It is important to
recognize that these differences in arrangements between workers and firms would arise in a
well-functioning labor market even in the absence of any government policies that affect the
labor market. The different arrangements exist because they are to the mutual benefit of
workers and firms.
Workers' preferences vary in many other respects. Workers may differ in their
preferences about the timing of work. For example, some workers may want to alternate
between long periods of intense work effort and leisure rather than working conventional 40-
hour weeks.
Workers may also have different preferences over the form of compensation they receive.
Workers may prefer cash compensation because they place a low value on the fringe benefits
supplied by the employer, or because employers provide more of the fringe benefits than
workers prefer. For example, some workers may consider themselves unlikely to need medical
care, so place little value on employer-paid health insurance. Other workers may already have
health insurance coverage through a spouse's employer and as an employee be unable to decline
the coverage and receive the employer's savings in the form of cash compensation. Workers
may also value pensions quite differently. A worker who knows she will change employers
before eligibility for pension benefits becomes vested would place no value on the employer's
pension contributions. Each of these preferences increases the likelihood that a worker would
prefer to be an independent contractor.**
Finally, workers may differ in their aversion to possible health and safety risks associated
with certain jobs. Since the insurability of such risks are quite different for employees and
independent contractors, workers who are risk-averse are more likely to be employees.
*• Note that cafeteria plans blur the distinction between the benefit flexibility of employees
and independent contractors.
39
Finns' Organization and Production Processes. Just as individuals have preferences
about the characteristics of firms, firms have preferences about the characteristics of workers.
These preferences are determined by a firm's organization and production processes and
therefore vary widely across firms. A firm's preference for workers determines the mix of
worker skills and preferences best suited to the firm.
Firms may differ in the amount of firm-specific knowledge they require of their workers.
Firms that require relatively little firm-specific knowledge may be less willing to make long-term
employment commitments to their workers than firms that require relatively high levels. Firms
may also have different costs of providing fringe benefits to their employees; larger firms
generally can provide benefits at lower costs.
Variability in the demand for their product may also differ among firms. Firms
experiencing greater variability may be less willing to make long-term employment commitments
to their workers, or at least to some of their workers, than firms with relatively more stable
product demand. Firms may differ in the production processes they use to produce similar
goods, leading to differences in the most suitable skill levels of their workers. Differences in
the way that firms organize themselves also can result in differences in the firms' abilities to
determine whether their workers actually accomplish the tasks for which they are paid. Firms
with higher monitoring costs may hire those workers they believe will require less monitoring
and supervision, or workers who are more willing to be monitored.
Arrangements Between Workers and Firms. The differences in workers' skills and
preferences and in firms' organization and production processes will lead to a diversity of
arrangements between workers and firms. These differences in workers and firms are found in
numerous combinations, so that a simple characterization of the diversity in firm/worker
arrangements is not possible.
Generally, firms that demand a high degree of control over their production process or
require workers to have a high level of firm-specific knowledge are more likely to enter into
long-term employer/employee arrangements with workers. Such arrangements are also more
likely for firms that have a sufficient scale to provide fringe benefits to workers at a lower cost
than the worker faces purchasing similar benefits directly. The workers who enter such
arrangements are likely to be more risk-averse, or to have higher preferences for fringe benefits.
Conversely, firms that can provide fringe benefits only at high costs or that have high costs of
monitoring and supervising workers are more likely to prefer independent contractor
arrangements with workers. Firms are also more likely to enter independent contractor
40
arrangements in circumstances where they have a high degree of variability over time in their
need for workers with specific skills. The workers who enter such arrangements generally
prefer more variety and autonomy, greater flexibility in scheduling work, and more cash
compensation than they would receive as employees.
Although firms generally enter into arrangements with workers directly, third parties may
be involved in certain circumstances. For example, short-term arrangements for experienced
or higher-skilled workers are often a small segment of these labor markets, so the cost to firms
and workers of locating each other and making matches may be quite high. Third parties such
as temporary worker organizations and brokers reduce such costs by gathering the necessary
information and making it available to firms and workers.
B. Government Policy
The diversity of arrangements between workers and firms reflects the outcome of well
functioning labor markets. This report proceeds from the assumption that a fundamental goal
of government policy should be to maintain the efficiency of labor markets, which generally
requires noninterference with diversity. Government intervention in labor markets is warranted
only in those relatively narrow and well-defined instances in which imperfections in the markets
result in inefficiencies or in which overriding social goals can be achieved, cost effectively,
through such intervention. Section V of this chapter briefly discusses such government
interventions.
m. NEUTRALITY IN TAX TREATMENT
A. Maintaining Labor Market Efficiency
Tax treatment that is neutral between employee and independent contractor status is
necessary to maintain labor market efficiency. Tax treatment that is not neutral creates artificial
incentives for workers to be classified as employees rather than independent contractors, or vice
versa. Although particular firms and workers may gain by responding to such artificial
incentives, the economy as a whole does not; aggregate labor market efficiency is reduced, as
are aggregate worker real income and firm production.
Determining the efficiency effects of section 1706 on the market for technical services
workers is difficult because the underlying efficiency of the market to which section 1706 applies
is unknown, and because that market had already been affected by prior legislation by the time
41
section 1706 was enacted.^* Thus, the previous efficiency of the market could not be taken for
granted.
Determining the efficiency effect of section 1706 is also complicated by the fact that
section 1706 is limited to situations involving a third-party broker. The limitation creates a
separate category of workers for employment tax purposes; depending on the effect of prior
legislation, the limitation could cause a non-neutrality in the market.
Section 1706 may also have indirectly affected worker classification. Publicity
surrounding section 1706 made workers and firms aware of the common law tests and the
correct interpretation of section 530. Workers and firms that had incorrectly believed that
section 530 required certain workers to be classified as independent contractors learned that it
did not. At the same time, by removing the relief in section 530 from employer penalties for
misclassifying technical services workers as independent contractors, section 1706 increased the
risk to some employers of misclassification.
It is reasonably certain that section 1706 reduced efficiency in some cases and increased
it in others. There is not enough information, however, to reach any conclusions about the
overall effect of section 1706 on labor market efficiency.
The TAMRA conferees requested an evaluation of the extent to which Section 1706 has
had a chilling effect on the ability of technical services personnel to get work. Assuming that,
prior to the enactment of section 1706, the compensation level of technical services workers did
not depend on their worker classification (although the compensation mix may have varied),
section 1706 should not have affected the total demand for technical services workers. As long
as the total compensation of independent contractors and employees is the same (although
perhaps paid in different forms), there is no reason to expect the total demand for technical
services workers to decline.
Although section 1706 probably did not reduce the overall demand for technical services
workers, it may have resulted in some workers being unable to find work with their accustomed
form of compensation and working conditions. Removing the safe harbor provision of section
^^ The prior legislation includes income and employment tax and labor law, section 530
restrictions on issuing guidance about classification under employment laws, and section 3509
reductions in employer costs for misclassification. Each of these pieces of legislation may have
reduced or increased the underlying market efficiency.
42
530 for technical services workers focused employers' attention on the need to classify workers
correctly. Some independent contractors may have been able to continue their current work only
as employees. If the classification change required the workers to accept a package of fringe
benefits in lieu of some amount of cash compensation, the value to them of their entire
compensation package may have changed. They would have been better off to the extent that
they considered the fringe benefit package and its accompanying tax-preferred benefits more
valuable than the loss in cash income. For example, workers who would previously have
preferred to be classified as employees, but were not because of resistance from service-
recipients, would be better off. Conversely, workers who did not find the substituted fringe
benefit package more valuable may have found the value of their income reduced. Similarly,
workers who would not have preferred to be classified as employees include those with
considerable trade or business expenses, whose opportunity to deduct these expenses would have
become constrained, and those who tended to understate receipts or overstate deductions. In
addition, workers whose classification was questionable and who were used to working through
brokers may have found that work as independent contractors could no longer be secured
through a broker; these workers may have been able to continue work as independent contractors
by contacting service-recipients directiy.
B. Tax Equity
Equitable tax treatment requires that taxpayers in equivalent situations, with the same
incomes, be taxed equally. Thus, providing equivalent tax treatment to employees and indepen-
dent contractors is required to insure tax equity between the two groups of workers. The
examples presented in Chapter 2 can be used to illustrate potential inequities in the tax treatment
of employees and independent contractors.^' As the discussion in Chapter 2 concluded, section
1706 does not systematically favor either status.
Worker with Typical Mix of Fringe Benefits. Example 1 , which is summarized in Table
2-2 in Chapter 2, shows the situation of an employee who receives total compensation of $1,000,
consisting of wages and a typical mix of fringe benefits. The worker does not have any
potentially deductible work-related expenses, such as union dues, home office expenses, or travel
expenses. The independent contractor receives the entire $1,000 in cash, out of which Federal
and State income taxes and the Social Security and Medicare taxes for self-employed workers
^* See Section in.C of Chapter 2 for a description of the approach taken in developing these
examples.
43
are paid, health insurance is purchased, and contributions to a tax-favored "Keogh" retirement
plan are made.
As shown in the bottom portion of Table 2-2, the money income of the self-employed
worker, after paying taxes and purchasing medical and retirement benefits, is $22 or about five
percent ($22/$475) lower than that of the employee. The $22 is the net of $34 of additional
taxes less $12 saved by not purchasing unemployment insurance and workers' compensation.
Thus, the self-employed worker' has $22 less money income despite not having the protection
of either unemployment insurance or workers' compensation. As explained in Chapter 2, taxes
are higher for the self-employed worker because that part of cash income which would have
purchased employer-paid fringe benefits is subject to Social Security and Medicare taxes and
some is also subject to income taxes. Thus, in Example 1, the differential treatment of certain
fringe benefits for tax purposes, especially for Social Security and Medicare taxes, causes an
inequitable distribution of taxes between employees and independent contractors."
Noncompliance. The administrative rules governing the form and timing of tax payments
and where income is reported on tax returns differ for employees and independent contractors,
with stricter rules generally applying to employees {see Chapter 2 and Appendix A). Thus,
independent contractors may have greater opportunity than employees to be less than fully
compliant with tax laws. If the situation in Example 1 is maintained, except that the independent
contractor understates net income from self-employment by five percent, the after-tax money
income of the independent contractor and the employee would be equal. That situation is
illustrated in Example 2 (Table 2-3). If the underreporting of net income were to exceed five
percent, the independent contractor would have a higher after-tax money income than the
employee.
Worker Expenses. Because worker expenses are treated more favorably for independent
contractors than for employees, workers who have such expenses are not taxed equally.
Example 3 (Table 2-4) illustrates the same situation as Example 1, except that the worker has
work-related expenses equal to ten percent of gross compensation. This level of worker
expenses is just sufficient to make the money income net of taxes and worker expenses of the
independent contractor equal to that of the employee. At higher levels of worker expenses, the
independent contractor would have a higher after-tax income.
" Note, however that because the independent contractor's Social Security taxes are being
paid on a higher level of income, his or her future Social Security benefits might also be slightly
higher.
44
No Voluntary Fringe Benefits. In Example 4 (Table 2-5), the employer provides only
those fringe benefits mandated by Federal or State law: Social Security and Medicare;
unemployment insurance, and workers' compensation. Otherwise, the facts are the same as in
Example 1. In Example 1, the net after- tax income of the independent contractor was $22, or
about five percent, lower than that of the employee. In Example 4, with no voluntary fringe
benefits, the results are reversed; the independent contractor's money income is $8, or 1 percent,
greater than the income of the employee. The independent contractor's greater after-tax income
is due to the cost of the employee's coverage under unemployment insurance and workers'
compensation and the income tax treatment of the employer's payments for that coverage.
Inequity does not arise directly from the difference in income stemming from the cost of
unemployment insurance and workers' compensation. Although the independent contractor has
a higher after-tax income because she does not make payments for such coverage, the
independent contractor also is not eligible for the benefits from these programs. The inequity
is due to the exclusion from the employee's taxable income of the employer payments for
unemployment insurance and workers' compensation.
Summary. The examples indicate that the difference in after-tax income between
employees and independent contractors would typically be quite small, if firms classify workers
correctly. The differences may be significant, however, for certain sets of worker preferences.
Thus, a worker who has substantial business expenses and no desire for employee benefits may
have much higher after-tax income as an independent contractor. Conversely, a worker who has
few business expenses and a strong desire for all the employee benefits that a firm offers may
have much higher after-tax income as an employee.
While it is possible for one set of tax differentials to offset another exactly, as Examples
2 and 3 illustrate, such exact offsets are unlikely in practice. The typical situation is for the
combined effects of the various differentials in tax treatment not to leave employees and
independent contractors treated exactly equally, and, therefore, to create inequities.
Even in cases where differences in the after-tax income of the worker are small, the
consequences of a retroactive IRS determination of misclassification may be significant for the
firm. Because the firm did not provide employee benefits to the independent contractor, the cash
compensation to the independent contractor generally had equalled the sum of the wage payment
which would have been received by an employee and the amount the employer would have spent
for employee benefits. With reclassification, the entire amount of cash compensation paid to the
independent contractor is deemed to have been wages that the firm would have paid to the
worker as an employee, and the employer's liability for Social Security and Medicare taxes and
45
for the withholding of income taxes is larger than if the firm had treated the worker as an
employee and divided the worker's compensation into taxable wages and non-taxable fringe
benefits.
Classifying workers as employees nominally shifts much of the tax compliance burden
to employers and permits tax collection through withholding, which is extremely efficient.
Similarly, employers incur the direct compliance costs of supplying legally-required as well as
voluntary, but somewhat regulated, fringe benefits. However, the extent to which such
compliance burdens are shifted to employees through reduced levels of compensation is not
known.
IV. ADMINISTRATIVE COSTS
Although compliance with tax laws is necessary, the administrative costs of compliance
divert resources from other uses. A goal of tax policy is, therefore, to minimize tax compliance
costs while achieving the desired level of efficiency and equity in the tax system. While the
principles are clear, implementing them can be difficult. The inherent tradeoffs between low
compliance costs, efficiency, and equity help explain some of the differentials in the tax
treatment of employees and independent contractors.
For example, the Federal Social Security and Medicare system generally taxes employees
on their stated salaries; it does not permit adjustments for various work-related expenses which
employees may incur. As a result of this simplification, the income to which the Social Security
and Medicare taxes are applied in the case of employees may be mismeasured: that is, it may
differ from their economic incomes. The mismeasurement may be significant in a small
percentage of cases, and both the tax liability and the effective tax rate may be higher than if
employees were taxed, as independent contractors are, on their net income from employment.
In this situation, the compliance burdens of employees are greatly reduced as a result of the
simplification, but at the cost of a certain degree of equity.^*
'* However, the benefits of excluding employer-paid fringe benefits from Social Security
and Medicare income bases for employees but not completely for independent contractors may
reduce or even outweigh the extra tax burden on employees from the failure to exclude
employees' work-related expenses from the employee's Social Security, Medicare, and income
tax bases. Moreover, workers' eventual disability or retirement benefits may be increased as
the result of the differential in Social Security tax treatment, thus partially offsetting any
potential equity loss.
46
Similarly, for income tax purposes, an employee cannot deduct any employment-related
expenses unless she itemizes deductions on her income tax return and unless these expenses
exceed two percent of income from all sources. Moreover, there are classes of expenses for
which a deduction is further limited or effectively prohibited. In contrast, an independent
contractor has much greater freedom to take such deductions for income (and Social Security
and Medicare) tax purposes. There are, however, compliance costs to the independent
contractor associated with this freedom. The costs include the burden of maintaining complete
sets of records which might not otherwise have to be maintained, the burdens and expense of
filing more complicated tax returns, and the costs of being excluded from using the highly
efficient payment system provided by the withholding of taxes by, and payment through, an
employer. In addition, the costs to the government of assuring compliance with tax laws through
examination of a sample of workers' tax returns and matching information from various
information documents against the information reported on workers' tax returns is usually higher
for self-employed taxpayers.
V. NON-TAX POLICIES
Federal and State governments have a number of non-tax policy objectives which affect
labor markets. Some of these may increase the efficiency of labor markets by reducing or
removing imperfections, and others may achieve various politically-determined goals. While
these policies may have important effects on workers' choices of arrangements with firms,
because this report focuses on specific tax policies, these non-tax policies are merely listed here.
The policies are: retirement security; access to health care; protection of workers (occupational
health and safety); unemployment security; employment standards (minimum wage and hours);
and nondiscrimination in employment practices. '*
Much of the legislation implementing non-tax policies applies only to employees, not to
independent contractors or other self-employed workers. The definition of an employee may
vary under different legislation, however, so that, for example, a limited number of workers
might be deemed independent contractors for tax purposes, while being deemed employees under
wage and hours legislation. Such differences may be warranted by the differences in policies
of the various legislation, but they do impose additional compliance costs on both firms and
workers. Much of the additional cost stems from the confusion caused by seemingly inconsistent
treatment, as Examples 2 and 3 illustrate.
39
Legislation implementing these policies is summarized in Chapter 2 and Appendix A.
CHAPTERS: TAX COMPLIANCE ISSUES
I. OVERVIEW
The TAMRA conferees questioned whether there were abuses in the reporting of income
by independent contractors (as compared to employees) that justified the adoption of section
1706. This question has been evaluated in terms of whether there was a significant revenue loss
attributable to noncompliance that section 1706 could have been expected to reduce.'"' Whether
this is true depends in part on (1) the extent of the misclassification of technical services workers
covered by section 1706 and (2) the noncompliance rate of such misclassified employees relative
to the rate that would be expected if they were properly classified. This chapter provides data
relevant to these questions.^'
n. RATE OF MISCLASSmCATION
IRS studies suggest that misclassification of employees as independent contractors is
significant."*^ Recent studies of this problem include the IRS' Strategic Initiative on Withhold-
ing Noncompliance (SVC-1).
^° The revenue effect also depends on the existence of other differences in the level of tax
paid by employees and independent contractors, e.g., the proportionately larger tax expenditures
associated with employee fringe benefits. These differences are discussed in Chapter 2 and
Appendix A to this report. They are not taken into account here, however, because their use
is not considered abusive within the meaning of the TAMRA conferees.
^' At the initial stage of this study, it was determined that existing IRS data would be used
in addressing these questions, and that no new surveys would be undertaken to measure the
compliance of technical services workers or the population of those who had been affected by
section 1706.
^^ See also GAG, Information Returns Can Be Used to Identify Employers Who Misclassify
Workers Appendix II, GGD-89-107 (1989). In that study, individuals receiving more than
$10,000 in income reportable on Form 1099 from one payor were identified. A random sample
of 408 of the payors was interviewed. The interviews indicated that 157 (138-176 at a 95
percent confidence level), or 38 percent, misclassified at least some of their employees as
independent contractors.
47
48
The employer portion of SVC-1 examined employment tax and withholding compliance
for tax year 1984 for a sample of 3,331 employers/' It includes an estimate of the percentage
of employers that misclassified at least some of their employees as independent contractors.**
Some of the results for different sectors are shown in Table 5-1. For purposes of the table,
employees were considered misclassified if they were determined to be employees under the
common law tests (regardless of whether section 530 applied), but had been treated as
independent contractors by their employers. Employers were considered to have misclassified
employees if they misclassified one or more of their employees, regardless of the total number
they misclassified.
Table 5-1 does not provide definitive proof that misclassification is a bigger problem
among employers subject to section 1706 than among other employers. The table indicates that
misclassification rates among employers in the service sector were not much higher than among
employers in other sectors in the sample population.^* It is difficult to estimate the percentage
of misclassified employees in each sector reliably because the SVC-1 survey was designed to
determine the frequency of employers that misclassify, rather than the frequency of misclassified
employees. It appears, however, that the percentage of service sector employees who were
misclassified was higher than in other sectors in the sample population, suggesting that
employers in the service sector that had misclassified employees tended to misclassify a larger
^^ The employers were selected at random from employers with previous employment tax
records (Form 940 or 941E) listed on the business master file (BMF) for 1984. Form 941 is
the Employer's Quarterly Federal Tax Return. State and local governments and other employers
that generally only withhold income taxes and do not pay FICA or FUTA taxes instead file
Form 94 IE, Quarterly Return of Withheld Federal Income Tax. Thus, the employer sample
does not include organizations with no employees or those that were legally required to file a
Form 941 or 941E for 1984, but had no previous records on the BMF.
*• The employer portion of SVC-1 also measured compliance with reporting requirements
with respect to employment tax returns and W-4 submittals, and compliance of U.S. citizens
claiming exemption from withholding on foreign-source income.
*^ Misclassification rates were not separately calculated for the section 1706 group because
the SVC-1 sample contained very few workers in technical fields (only about 0.4 percent), and
because the SVC-1 survey did not gather sufficient data to identify employers in these fields that
were actually subject to section 1706.
in
3
H
u
•*^
s
a
0)
o
'35
"3
O
"a
o
G
1)
U
5^
■~ s s >■
uj .2 2 ^
S *• w u 1
^P ^P ^> ^p ^p wp
(^ lyv (^ (^t (^ ^^
r- 00 — o\ rj 00
<^0
f
£ £
i2 -5
E i :^ - ®
w is ^ c '-s
f.'S n. ■"
f E 2
z w
V
E D
u
o to
vOOv>0 — 0>r)0\0
)^ MP 1^ 1^ tf t^ MP
o»k (^ tyi (y^ O^ 1^ (^
0» ©V VO f^ ^ VO >0
o\ o\ >o On ri
t^
o
00
o
•* 00 —
ts fS r~
m ts wi
«^
o
in
OS
00
U-l
<N
o
in
»N
(N
0\
\r>
r-
00
»o
00
U-1
vo m
— — o r~
o
O
ON
00
On
NO
>ri On •* l»-
m — fs •*
•* 00 NO (S
s
mtsirir-iii^'* — 00
ONNOONfSNO — csiri
iriNOON — NOl/^>nON
NO NO
m On
IT)
«s
On — "- 00 00 On
p* 00 rf Tt NO NO
r~- t^i 00 \n
vn
NO O NO 00 IT) — fS
00 NO r— 00 o NO r-
rs (S (S cN es fN ra
Tj- — in Tt rJ t~
NO ts m r^ 00 ro
ts — ts — r4 rr
1
«
•2
3
VI
D
u
_o
■s
8
2
OS
•T3
1
>^
•a
—
§
>
i
5
t>
eo
k«
2
O
60
w
•a
i
u
_.
1
g*
c
a
•c
■^
O
g
3
^
1)
(U
2
2
c
c
J=
s
u
•c
o
c
'5
o
eo
_c
'S
5
§
u
u
E
§
u
2
3
■c
E.
tf
"o
.5
u
'E
CI
!>0
i
E
u
>
o
U
5
UJ
o
Z
V
>
I
o
■-
<
H
O
50
percentage of their employees.** This may reflect the fact that the service sector contains a
disproportionate number of smaller employers, and studies suggest that smaller employers
misclassify a larger percentage of their employees. (It may also reflect somewhat greater
difficulty in applying the common law tests of employee status in the service sector.)
For several reasons, no strong conclusions can be drawn from the SVC-1 data regarding
current misclassification patterns among employers subject to section 1706. First, there have
been significant changes in the tax laws and IRS enforcement activity since 1984, which may
have affected employers' abilities and incentives to misclassify workers.*' Second, the SVC-1
survey covered a relatively small sample of employers and has a relatively high sampling error
for small populations. Third, the population from which the sample was drawn included mainly
service-recipients that reported having at least some employees, and did not include service-
recipients that treated all of their workers as independent contractors.
Finally, misclassification rates for employers subject to section 1706 could not be
specifically determined from the data. The service sector misclassification rate may be
indicative of the rate for employers subject to section 1706, since service brokers would tend
to be classified in the service sector. The service-recipients may be in any industry, however,
including manufacturing or government. There may be reason to believe that, regardless of the
sector to which they are allocated, the relatively independent nature of the work done by
employees covered by section 1706, and the frequently temporary nature of the employment
relationship, may create a misleading appearance of independent contractor status under the
common law tests. In addition, the particular importance of computers in this area, and the
greater ease with which independent contractors can deduct their legitimate computer-related
expenses, may create an incentive to misclassify such employees as independent contractors.
in. RATE OF NONCOMPLIANCE
Misclassification can cause compliance problems if misclassified employees have a
greater tendency to underpay their taxes, whether due to underreporting of income, overstate-
** Service firms in the SVC-1 sample accounted for about 19 percent of reclassified workers
but only ten percent of W-2 forms. In contrast, the percentage of employers in the service
sector that had at least one misclassified employee was only slightly higher than for all
employers in the survey (Table 5-1).
*' See generally Appendix A.
51
ment of deductions, nonpayment of reported liabilities, or other factors. In fact, IRS studies
consistently find lower compliance rates for non-wage compensation income than for wage
income.** Recent studies include the 1985 Tax Compliance Measurement Program (TCMP)
and the employee portion of the 1984 SVC-1 survey. The 1985 TCMP is more comprehensive,
but is less useful for the specific purposes of this report than the 1984 SVC-1 survey because
the former covers all workers rather than just misclassified employees— the only group actually
affected by section 1706.
A. 1985 TCMP
The 1985 TCMP measured wages. Schedule C gross profit, and other categories of
income and deduction reported by a randomly-selected sample of 50,000 individual taxpayers,
compared them to the correct amounts (determined after an examinations of the taxpayers'
returns), and expressed the ratios as voluntary reporting percentages (VRP).*' Data from the
survey were then used to estimate the values for the entire population of taxpayers from which
the sample was selected. The results are shown in Table 5-2. For purposes of this table, the
sample data have been divided between employees and independent contractors, *° and between
technical services workers and other workers.*'
** In addition to the IRS and GAO studies cited above, these include IRS studies of (1) 1975
and 1976 information returns (covering filers receiving commissions or fees); (2) 1979 Forms
1099-NEC (covering filers receiving nonemployee compensation); and (3) 1977 delinquent
Forms 1099-MISC (follow-up study covering U.S. residents required to file Form 1040).
*' See generally Fratanduono & Bucci, Trends in the Voluntary Compliance of Taxpayers
Who File Individual Income Tax Returns, in Department of the Treasury, Internal Revenue
Service, 1989 Update, Trend Analyses and Related Statistics, Document 6011 (1989).
*° For this purpose, employees are defined as individuals with over $10,000 in wage income
(as examined), and more wages than Schedule C income, while independent contractors are
defined as those with over $10,000 in Schedule C income (as examined), more Schedule C
income than wage income, and less than $5,000 in wage payments. Using this definition,
approximately three percent of the taxpayers in the entire weighted TCMP sample were
independent contractors, 55 percent were employees, and 41 percent did not fall into either
category. For technical services workers, two percent of the sample were independent
contractors, 92 percent were employees, and six percent did not fall into either category.
*' See Appendix C for a definition of technical services worker used for this purpose.
09
fa
u
o
a
fa
u I
** o
s
•o
B
0)
a
«
S
hN
s
es
a
S
1
u
1
►>
^
.£
£
w
u
1^
r
(A
e
i
V
^
a
^
X
c
s
es
s
o
u
DC
a
'■*^
fa
o
a
<«-| .2
<« |.2
8* IS
0£ i£
O 01 E
II
<« r .2
t^ (^ (^ t>; (^ t^ t>S
«M >ri — ov r^ ^ t~-
C^ C^ C^ v^ C^ v^ ^^
O P-) 00 O — m O
S^
^
S'
to
00
00
00
^.«
•«r
o
o
«s
r-
o\
0\
o\
^
«^
Ov
0\
o
Ov
0\
r~
t»-
t-
— n ■* Ov 00 o o
in
9> to 00
t^ rs o
OS vo
>0 SO
On O OS >0 vO
vd r4 ' ' ■
o
rM —
_ - . vi IT) IT) o
— p «M so »o o» o
OS OS On ^* O 0\ ^
— r- »»s rj *^ NO 00
r^ m (s p^ \o T^
>o <o so
<s <s ■^ —
o —
r~ O fn p^ t~- ^ OS
— OS — r~ ^ t~ r--
1
E
U
E
I
B
e
^^^ ^^^ ^9 ^^ ^^ ^^ ^^
^^ ^^ ^^ ^^ ^^ ^^ ^r^
O (S m m so 00 o
8" «X •^ P^ O 00 OS
Os OS — IT) OS OS
— — TT so OS O *
c
^^^ ^Xk ^^ fcJS^ ^^ ^^ ^^
Wv (T*. ^S U"» ^N. (^ On
■^ O OS Tt Tf OS —
8
m m r^ ro m
OS — 00 00 00
— m <s —
O r^ O
t~ 00
— m O 00 in r^ O
— ^ ^ — fsi i»i ^
— q rj os ^ ov so
-- rn rj — < O O 00
-- ^ 00 o — — ^
-- •^ rn rj CS r^ p^
e
W
_o
CA
Q.
c
u
'u
u:
s
4)
(A
2
S
Ou
en
2
O
1
o
1
i
1
■c
"5
o
u
u
u
Z
u
2
o
C/}
_«
JD
JU
JJ
1
fid
VD
"5
"s
"5
^
H
&
•s
•s
"S
•s
S
1
flO
f
^
f
^
f
^
^
(^
cJ5
^
{2
g
w
O
te
c
•^
Q.
u
"C
C
3
4i
t-
^
2
"S
iH
E
0
u
i
en
0
cu
Q
3
2
a.
o
o
c
i>
k.
o
u
t/3
•c
u
O
i-
Z
o
u
u
u
U
u
U4
V)
u
V
JD
_u
;s
ed
VI
3
"a
"a
3
H
00
•s
■B
•2
•B
3
2
a
J=
f
^
f
<
^
o
o
60
to
^
c
E
e
I
E
o
U
53
Table 5-2 shows that the VRPs for the Schedule C income (and total taxable income) of
the independent contractors included in the 1985 TCMP were generally worse than the
comparable VRPs for the wages (and total taxable income) of employees, but that both measures
were generally better for technical services workers than for other workers. It also shows that
underreporting of income was not the only reason for the independent contractors' low VRPs:
in particular, the low VRPs for their net Schedule C income also resulted from the overstatement
of the cost of goods sold and/or operations (resulting in underreporting of Schedule C gross
profit), and the overstatement of other Schedule C deductions (resulting in underreporting of
Schedule C net profit). The overstatement of Schedule C deductions contributes about two-thirds
of the total understatement of net profit shown for technical services independent contractors.
Some of the reported overstatement of deductions may have been attributable to inadequate
record-keeping.
For independent contractors, the actual reporting of Schedule C income may have been
slightly better than indicated. Table 5-2 shows that wages and salaries tend to be slighdy
overreported by independent contractors, whereas Schedule C gross receipts tend to be slightly
underreported. Some of the wage and salary overreporting may be due to Schedule C income
being reported incorrectly as wage or salary income, however, which may lead to failure to
collect any Social security or Medicare tax on that income. Thus, actual Schedule C VRPs may
be somewhat higher than shown on Table 5-2. Also, it may be particularly hard for IRS
examiners to detect wage and salary underreporting when the underreporting is due to collusion
between employers and employees. Thus, actual wage and salary VRPs may not be as high as
reported as shown on Table 5-2.
General conclusions drawn from the TCMP data with respect to workers actually covered
by section 1706 are subject to several reservations. First, it was impossible to calculate separate
VRPs for such workers, so a broader group of technical services workers was used a proxy. *^
The compliance patterns in the two groups may have been different. Second, there have been
significant changes in the tax laws and IRS enforcement activity since 1985 that may have
affected individuals' incentive and ability to underreport their income or overstate their
deductions. Specifically, the tightening of the requirements for certain business deductions in
TRA 1986 may have reduced the extent to which itemized deductions and Schedule C deductions
" See Appendix C for a description of the occupations included in this group.
54
are overstated.*' Third, the population from which the sample was drawn includes only
individuals for whom a return was filed, and thus the data do not measure compliance in the so-
called "underground" economy. Fourth, as indicated above, it was not possible to distinguish
misclassified workers from other workers in the TCMP sample. Therefore, the data relates to
the relative compliance of independent contractors generally, rather than the narrower group of
misclassified employees actually affected by section 1706. Finally, the VRPs are not adjusted
to reflect TCMP audit sustension rates and, therefore, may not indicate the actual revenue
potential from legislative or administrative changes affecting compliance.
B. 1984 SVC-1 Employee Survey
As explained above, the SVC-1 survey examined employment tax and withholding
compliance for a sample of businesses for tax year 1984. The employer portion of the survey
identified employees who were misclassified (by their employers) as independent contractors.
A follow-up survey of 3,260 misclassified employees was also conducted to determine their level
of individual reporting compliance. Data covering the 2,406 employees for whom a Form 1099
had been filed were then weighted to represent values for the entire population of misclassified
employees.*^ Misclassified technical services workers were found to have reported 92.6
percent of their misclassified compensation. For other workers, the VRP was 77 percent of
misclassified compensation. Other data from the employee portion of the SVC-1 survey suggest
that information reporting may also play a substantial role in subsequent compliance by
misclassified employees."
" See, e.g., the discussion of the two-percent floor on itemized deductions and sections
280A and 280F in Appendix A.
^ Forms 1099 had been filed for 37 of the 43 technical services workers and 2,369 of the
3,217 other workers in the misclassified employee sample. The sub-sample used to generate the
estimates in the table was limited to employees for whom a Form 1099 had been filed because
these are the only employees covered by section 530, and the issue for resolution is whether
section 530 protection for misclassified workers has permitted significant compliance problems
to develop.
'* The survey found that information returns were filed for 84 percent of misclassified
employees in the sample whose payments exceeded $600. While 77.2 percent of the
misclassified compensation for which a Form 1099 was filed was reported, only 28.8 percent
of the misclassified compensation for which no Form 1099 was filed was reported. This
contrasts with the results of a 1977 study, in which misclassification was not an issue, which
55
The data from the employee portion of the SVC-1 generally suffer from the same
problems as the TCMP data described above. In addition, the small number of technical
services workers covered by the survey means that any differences found between them and
other workers have a high sampling error. The TCMP data also indicate that Schedule C
reporting of both income and deductions for workers whose primary source of income is
Schedule C income is superior to that of workers who have only occasional Schedule C income.
This is true for both technical services workers and other workers. There is no way to
determine from the data whether there are differences in Schedule C reporting for correctly
classified independent contractors and those who are incorrectly classified. Furthermore,
workers covered by section 1706 may have more than one job during a year, and may be
misclassified in one job but not another. Thus, correct classification may not result in correct
reporting of the entire Schedule C amount.
C. Summary
The 1985 TCMP and the 1984 SVC-1 misclassified employee survey suggest that there
is more underreporting of income by independent contractors than by employees. They do not,
however, support assertions that technical services workers are less compliant than other
workers. Taken together, the 1985 TCMP and 1984 SVC-1 data suggest that the reporting of
non-wage income by workers covered by section 1706 is at least as good as, and perhaps
superior to, reporting by other misclassified workers, but not as good as the reporting of wage
and salary income. The 1985 TCMP also indicates that overstatement of deductions is
responsible for much of the understatement of net profit for independent contractors in technical
services (and independent contractors in general).
found that 83.2 percent of the compensation for which no Form 1099 MISC was filed was
reported.
CHAPTER 6: TAX ADMINISTRATION ISSUES
I. OVERVIEW
The TAMRA conferees questioned whether there were problems with the administration
of section 1706 itself, or with the common law tests that employers subject to section 1706 must
generally use in classifying workers as employees or independent contractors. This chapter
addresses these issues and concludes that both the scope of section 1706 and the common law
tests could be further clarified.
n. ADMINISTRATIVE PROBLEMS WITH SECTION 1706
Compared to section 530, section 1706 raises few administrative or interpretive issues.
Those that have arisen concern primarily its effect (including its relationship to the common law
tests for determining employee status) and its scope (including the occupations covered under
it).
Many taxpayers were initially confused about the effect of section 1706, believing that
it required that the individuals covered by the provision be treated as employees. Apparently,
some service-recipients reacted by treating all their technical services workers as employees,
even though that was sometimes contrary to the results under the common law tests. This
misconception probably sprang from some imprecise language in the legislative history of the
provision" and an IRS publication issued soon after enactment," plus the common misconcep-
tion that section 530 had previously required that these individuals be treated as independent
contractors regardless of whether there was a basis for doing so. This misconception has been
largely corrected through a combination of industry education and IRS guidance, which
" See footnote 3 1 above.
" In January, 1987, the IRS published a revised Publication 15 (Circular E) which
discussed section 530 and Stated that "[i]f you have any reason for treating a worker other than
as an employee you will not be liable for employment taxes on payments to the worker. This
relief is not available, however, for any arrangement you may have for services provided to you
by certain technical personnel, such as engineers, computer programmers, and systems analysts."
In Resource Technical Consultants (U.S.A.), Inc. v. Baker, 88-1 U.S.T.C. 1 9111 at 83,033
(S.D.N. Y. 1987), the district court found that "the Circular makes no misstatements and is at
worst confusing."
57
58
explained that technical services workers would "be classified as independent contractors or
employees under generally applicable common law standards.""
Many taxpayers are still confused about the scope of section 1706, in particular about the
occupations it covers. The provision mentions "engineers, designers, drafters, computer
programmers, systems analysts and other similarly skilled workers engaged in a similar line of
work." These terms are not defined in the legislative history, however, and are not well defined
in other sources.*' Nor do they correspond well to industry usage or to the occupational
categories used by the IRS for Schedule C purposes. The phrase "similarly skilled workers
engaged in a similar line of work" is particularly vague, since it is not clear how much similarity
is required. For example, are scientists included if they are engaged in engineering-type
activities, such as oil exploration, or are they excluded because they do not have similar skills
to engineers? Are architects included because they often perform drafting, or was the term
"drafting" meant to be read more narrowly for purposes of section 1706? These problems have
made it difficult in some cases for employers to identify covered workers and for the IRS
systematically to target such workers for enforcement or even to gather sufficient data on their
levels of compliance.
m. ADMINISTRATIVE PROBLEMS WITH COMMON LAW TESTS OF EMPLOYEE
STATUS
As explained in Chapter 2, whether an individual is an employee for Federal tax purposes
is generally determined under the common law tests for determining whether an employment
relationship exists. As explained in Chapter 3, section 530 allows employers to rely on their
own erroneous classification under some circumstances. Section 1706 denies this relief to
certain employers in the technical services field, and thus requires these employers to apply the
common law tests in all cases. In a sense, section 1706 restores pre-section 530 law for these
employers.
" Notice 87-19, 1987-1 C.B. 455; News Release IR-87-8 (January 21, 1987); News Release
IR-87-68 (May 21, 1987). This guidance also clarified that section 1706 applies only to brokers
or job-shops, and does not apply to service-recipients generally,
*' See, e.g., U.S. Department of Labor, Employment &. Training Administration,
Dictionary of Occupational Tides (4th ed. 1977 &. Supp. 1986).
59
The common law tests, like most facts-and-circumstances tests, lack precision and
predictability. Since they were developed in an entirely different context from Federal tax law
(primarily the law of employer liability for employee torts), they may also produce inappropriate
results for some tax purposes. As then-Assistant Secretary (Tax Policy) John Chapoton stated
in 1982, "[i]n many cases, applying the common law test in employment tax issues does not
yield clear, consistent, or satisfactory answers[,] and reasonable persons may differ as to the
correct classification. "*°
Although the subjectivity of the common law tests is no doubt one problem,*' a bigger
problem may be the large number of factors with which taxpayers and the IRS must contend,
and the consequent difficulty in determining the relative weight of any one factor." Thus, an
important feature of many proposed legislative solutions has been to limit the number of factors
to be taken into account.*'
The common law tests may be particularly difficult to apply in the multi-party contract
situations, which are the only situations covered by section 1706. This is because the service-
broker and the service-recipient often share control over the service-provider's performance of
*° Hearings Before the Subcommittee on Oversight of the Internal Revenue Service of the
Committee on Finance, 97th Cong., 2d Sess. (April 26, 1982). See also Hearings Before the
Subcommittee on Commerce, Consumer and Monetary Affairs of the Committee on Government
Operations, 101st Cong., 1st Sess. (May 16, 1989) (acting Commissioner of Internal Revenue
stating that "[o]ne of the most difficult and controversial issues in the employment tax area is
the definition of 'employee' under the so-called 'common law rules' .... IRS' preference has
been and continues to be for a legislative solution.").
*' See, e.g. , GAO, Information Returns Can Be Used to Identify Employers Who Misclassifi/
Workers 3, GGD-89-107 (1989).
*^ In an August 5, 1987 letter to Lawrence B. Gibbs, Commissioner of Internal Revenue,
Frank S. Swain, the U.S. Small Business Administration Chief Counsel for Advocacy, requested
that the IRS clarify which factors are important, and which are not important, in determining
employee status in the technical services area.
" See, e.g., the proposals described in Hearings Before the Subcommittee on Select
Revenue Measures of the Committee on Ways and Means, 97th Cong., 2d Sess. (June 11, 1982)
(joint Statement of John E. Chapoton, Assistant Secretary of the Treasury (Tax Policy), and
Roscoe L. Egger, Jr., Commissioner of Internal Revenue).
60
services, as well as sharing other incidents of employment.** In some cases, both may
legitimately be considered the individual's employer. While the parties may request a
determination letter from the IRS, this may be too difficult and time-consuming to be
practical." Moreover, even if the service-recipient is considered the individual's sole
employer, the broker may have sufficient control over payments made to the individual to be
treated as her "imputed employer" and be subject to a withholding requirement.** Finally, even
if the broker is considered the sole employer, the client may be treated as the employer for
certain employee fringe benefit purposes under the leased employee rules. *^
Problems with the common law tests have been exacerbated by the fact that labor markets
have undergone significant changes-including the proliferation of multi-party arrangements-
since the enactment of section 530 in 1978, during which period section 530 has virtually
prevented the IRS from issuing any general guidance reflecting its interpretation of the common
law tests. This has made it very difficult for taxpayers and IRS personnel alike to analyze
employment relationships consistently, and has greatly reduced employers' ability to predict
when the common law tests require a particular worker to be treated as an employee or
independent contractor. The enactment of section 1706 has permitted the IRS to issue
guidance** in some very narrow circumstances, only, and significant gaps therefore remain.
** The situation becomes even more complicated when the individual operates through a
corporation. See Appendix A for a discussion of the relevance of incorporation in this context.
** For a third-party broker with dozens of independent contractors at many different clients,
the number of determination letter requests (Form SS-8) to be completed—even if a sampling is
used— can be very large if the firm wants to cover all typical factual settings. Moreover, client
projects often last only weeks or months, making it difficult to obtain a ruling before the
independent contractor changes job settings.
** Code § 3401(d)(1); Treas. Reg. § 31.3401(d)-l(f). See One v. United States, 419 U.S.
43 (1974).
*^ See Code § 414(n). Section 1706 does not affect the application of section 414(n). Staff
of the Joint Committee on Taxation, 100th Cong., 1st Sess., General Explanation of the Tax
Reform Act of 1986, 1345 (Comm. Print 1987).
*' See, e.g., Rev. Rul. 87-41, 1987-1 C.B. 296.
PART FOUR
APPENDICES
APPENDIX A
DIFFERENCES IN TREATMENT OF EMPLOYEES AND
INDEPENDENT CONTRACTORS-DETAILED ANALYSIS
I. OVERVIEW
Employees and employers face significantly different treatment from independent
contractors and their clients under a wide range of laws, including Federal and State employment
tax, income tax and labor laws. Differences that significantly favor one group over the other
may encourage deliberate misclassification of an individual as an employee or independent
contractor. This appendix describes the major differences in treatment between employees and
employers on the one hand and independent contractors and their clients on the other, and the
factors used to distinguish between them. It also compares the relative advantages of both types
of treatment and attempts to determine whether current law creates unnecessary incentives for
misclassification. It concludes that current law does not consistently favor one classification
over the other.
n. FEDERAL TAX LAW
A. Employment Taxes
Social Security and Medicare. Wages paid to employees are generally subject to Social
Security and Medicare taxes under the Federal Insurance Contribution Act (FICA).
Compensation paid to independent contractors, by contrast, is generally subject to Social
Security and Medicare taxes under the Self-Employment Contributions Act (SEC A).
69
Since 1990, the combined tax rates on employees and their employers on the one hand
and independent contractors and their clients on the other have been virtually identical under
both FICA and SEC A.™ Prior to 1983, the tax rates on independent contractors were
<*' See Code Subtitle A, Chapter 2, and Subtitle C, Chapter 21.
''" The combined Social Security and Medicare tax rate for 1991 is the same (15.3 percent)
underboth. Code §§ 1401, 3101 and 3111. Under both, only the first $53,400 of compensation
is subject to Social Security tax, while the first $125,000 is subject to Medicare tax. Code
§§ 1402(k) and 3121(x), as added by the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1990 (OBRA
1990), Pub. L. No. 101-508, 104 Stat. 1388 (1990); Notice, 55 Fed. Reg. 45856 (October 31,
63
64
significantly lower, even though they were generally eligible for the same Social Security and
Medicare benefits as employees." In 1982 testimony, Treasury recommended that the rate
differential be reduced to "help neutralize the decision whether to hire an independent contractor
or an employee, and relieve pressure on the question of employment status."^ 1983 legislation
mostly eliminated the rate differential effective in 1984, and made other conforming changes that
became fully effective in 1990."
Some differences still remain, however. In some cases they can be significant. While
the gross tax base is generally the same under PICA and SEC A,'''' items that reduce PICA
wages generally do not reduce compensation subject to SECA tax unless they are deductible on
Schedule C for income tax purposes. In particular, contributions to a qualified pension plan or
an accident and health plan generally are not includible in employee PICA wages, but are subject
to SECA tax.'* Contributions to certain nonqualified plans may also receive more favorable
1990). While, technically, the employer pays half of the PICA taxes imposed on an employee's
wages, the economic effect is the same as if the employee paid the entire amount. Special
deductions are also provided to self-employed individuals subject to SECA, which produce
nearly the same effect as the fact that employees are not subject to income or PICA taxes on the
employer's share of PICA. Code §§ 164(f) and 1402(a)(12).
"" In 1980, for example, the combined PICA tax rate (employer and employee) was 12.26
percent, while the combined SECA tax rate was 8.1 percent.
'^ Hearings Before the Subcommittee on Oversight of the Internal Revenue Service of the
Committee on Pinance, 97th Cong., 2d Sess. (April 26, 1982) (Statement of John E. Chapoton,
Assistant Secretary of the Treasury (Tax Policy)).
" Social Security Amendments of 1983, Pub. L. No. 98-21, § 124, 97 Stat. 65, 89 (1983).
See also H.R. Conf. Rep. No. 47, 98th Cong., 1st Sess. 125-26 (1983).
74
Commissioner v. Braddock, 95 T.C. No. 45 (1990).
''* Compare Code ^% 1402(a) and 3121(a)(5); 5ee Code § 62(a)(6). Health and accident plan
contributions are included in SECA compensation even though they are partially deductible for
income tax purposes. See Code §§ 162(1)(4). The treatment of pension plan contributions may
be explained by viewing contributions by self-employed persons as essentially elective.
Employee elective contributions are includible in PICA wages. Code § 3121(v)(l). This
explanation does not apply to accident and health plan contributions, however, since these may
be excluded from PICA wages even when provided under an elective arrangement. Code
§ 3121(a)(5)(G).
65
treatment under FICA.'* These advantages are to a limited extent offset, however, by the fact
that trade or business expenses may be deducted from compensation before SECA compensation
is calculated, but cannot be so deducted for PICA purposes, and that excess PICA taxes may be
imposed on the employer when an employee changes jobs in mid-year.^ Pinally, unlike
employees, independent contractors who are eligible for Social Security benefits can sometimes
avoid application of the Social Security earnings test through the use of deferred compensa-
tion.''*
Unemployment Insurance. The first $7,000 of wages paid to an employee is generally
subject to tax under the Pederal Unemployment Tax Act (PUTA).'' Under the integrated
Pederal/State system, part of the tax is ordinarily paid to the State of employment, while part
is paid to the Federal government; the combined rate averaged approximately 2.8 percent in
■'^ There is no analogue to section 3121(v)(2) in SECA. OBRA 1990 deleted an analogous
rule for corporate directors in section 1402(a) for tax purposes; however, a similar rule still
exists for purposes of the Social Security earnings test. See Social Security Act § 211(a), 42
U.S.C. § 411(a).
^ This results from the fact that, in computing PICA taxes on a new employee's wages,
an employer generally may not take into account the fact that the employee has already earned
wages in excess of the taxable wage base. Treas. Reg. § 31.3121(a)(l)-l(a)(3). If this results
in an overpayment, the employee may be entitled to a refund, but not the employer. Code
§ 6413(b); Treas. Reg. § 31.6413(c)-l; Rev. Rul. 55-584, 1955-2 C.B. 394. SECA taxes are
also considered income taxes, which are collected through the estimated tax system. Thus, while
PICA taxes are generally collected and deposited with the Federal government every pay period,
SECA taxes are generally paid quarterly. Compare Treas. Reg. §§ 1. 1401-l(a) and 31.6302(c)-
1. Similarly, SECA taxes may be contested in the Tax Court, while PICA taxes may not.
'* Under the Social Security earnings test, benefits through age 69 are reduced by a fraction
of the payee's other earnings in excess of an exemption amount. Social Security Act § 203, 42
U.S.C. § 403. In the case of an independent contractor, deferred compensation is generally
taken into account for this purpose when it is received, whereas, in the case of an employee,
deferred compensation is generally taken into account when earned. Compare Social Security
Act §§ 209 and 211, 42 U.S.C. §§ 409 and 411 (as noted above, an exception is provided for
deferred directors' fees). Therefore, some independent contractors defer receipt of compensation
that would otherwise reduce their Social Security benefits until after age 70.
79
See generally Code Subtitle C, Chapter 23.
66
1990. The Federal portion of the tax is paid quarterly. Independent contractors are not subject
to FUTA tax, but likewise generally are not eligible to receive any unemployment benefits.*"
B. Income Taxes
Collection Mechanisms. Income taxes on employees are collected mainly through the
withholding system, whereas income taxes on independent contractors are collected mainly
through the estimated tax system. Both systems are backed up by information reporting
requirements imposed on service-recipients.
Employers are generally required to withhold a portion of their employees' wages as they
are paid and remit it to the Federal government as payment of the employees' income taxes.*'
Withholding rates are specified in tables and procedures published by the IRS, and are calculated
to collect approximately the same amount of tax as the employees will ultimately owe with
respect to the wages if they work all year at the same wage level. *^ Withholding must
generally be done at the same rate each pay period,'^ and the amounts withheld must generally
be deposited, along with FICA taxes, soon thereafter in a Federal depositary.*^ Withholding
can generate significant overhead expenses.** Independent contractors and their clients
*° Eligibility is a matter of State rather than Federal law. See footnotes 140 and 143 below
for a discussion of State eligibility standards.
*' See generally Code § 31 and Subtitle C, Chapter 24.
*^ See generally Code § 3402; IRS Publication 15 (Circular E), Employer's Tax Guide (Rev.
January, 1991). Withholding rates are generally based on the employee's rate of compensation,
marital status, and the number of allowances claimed on Form W-4. Withholding rates may be
increased if an employee anticipates receiving additional income during a taxable year that is not
subject to withholding, or reduced if large deductions are anticipated.
*' But see, e.g.. Announcement 85-113, 1985-31 I.R.B. 31 (special accounting rule for
fringe benefits); cf. Code § 3501(b).
^ The actual schedule depends on the size of the payroll. See Treas. Reg. § 31.6302(c)-l.
** Some argue that the government is the main beneficiary of withholding, in that it enables
tax authorities to shift a large portion of the collection burden to the private sector. On the other
hand, it is not clear that withholding is any more burdensome on employers than increased
estimated tax payments (which would be necessary without withholding) would be on employees.
Withholding may also provide benefits to some employers because they have the use of withheld
funds for a short period of time before they must remit them to the government. Moreover,
67
generally are not subject to a withholding requirement with respect to their compensation
income.
Unless certain exceptions apply, both employees and independent contractors must pay
their estimated income tax liabilities for the current year in quarterly installments throughout the
year.*"^ The installments are due on April 15, June 15, September 15, and January 15 of the
following year. The amount of each installment is generally one quarter of the lesser of the
taxpayer's income tax liability for the prior year, or 90 percent of her liability for the current
year. Because of withholding, however, employees generally do not have to make any estimated
tax payments. This is because withholding generally requires earlier payments than would be
necessary under the estimated tax system, and these amounts are credited towards employees'
estimated tax obligations.*' Thus, employees are generally only required to make estimated
tax payments if they have significant non-wage income.
Employers generally must report all wages paid to an employee annually on Forms
W-2.** Similarly, clients must generally report all compensation paid to independent
contractors annually on Form 1099-MISC; no Form 1099-MISC is generally required, however,
for payments to a corporation, payments that are not made by a business (e.g., homeowners'
payments to a house painter), or payments to a service-provider aggregate less than $600 in a
calendar year.*' The administrative burden is about the same for each.
Copies of Form W-2 must be sent to the employee and to the Social Security
Administration. '^ The Social Security Administration subsequently sends information from the
forms to the IRS. Also, the employee is required to attach any copies she receives to her
income tax return. Using this information, the IRS can determine whether wages have been
employers may be able to shift some of their administrative costs of withholding to the worker
in the form of lower compensation.
86
See generally Code §§ 6315 and 6654.
" Code § 6654(g).
Code § 6041 A; Treas. Reg. §§ 1.6041-l(a) and 1.6041-2.
Code § 6041; Treas. Reg. §§ 1.6041-1 and 1.6041-3.
Code § 6051; Treas. Reg. §§ 31.6051-1 and 31.6051-2.
88
89
90
68
underreported. While 1099s must be sent to the independent contractor and the IRS, there is
no requirement that they be attached to an individual's return.
Trade or Business Expense Deductions. Under current law, independent contractors face
significantly fewer restrictions on their ability to deduct trade or business expenses than
employees. In particular, employees (but not independent contractors) generally may not deduct
their trade or business expenses unless they itemize their deductions on their Federal income tax
returns, and even then only to the extent they exceed two percent of their adjusted gross income
from all sources. Also, they must satisfy additional requirements before they may deduct their
automobile, home office and certain other expenses.
Independent contractors' trade or business expenses are generally deductible "above-the-
line", i.e., as a direct reduction in their business income reported on Schedule C. Employees'
trade or business expenses, by contrast, are generally only deductible "below-the-line", i.e., as
itemized expenses." Especially for lower-income employees, use of the standard deduction
is often more favorable than itemization of expenses; such individuals effectively get no tax
benefit from their trade or business expenses.*^ In addition, since 1986, employees' trade or
business expenses have generally been deductible only to the extent they (plus any other
miscellaneous itemized deductions) exceed two percent of the employee's adjusted gross income
from all sources.'^
The two-percent floor generally does not apply to an employee's trade or business
expenses to the extent they are reimbursed by her employer: in such case, generally no
deduction is necessary, because the reimbursement is not included in the employee's taxable
income in the first place. Only reimbursement arrangements that require the employee to
account to the employer for any expenditures are eligible for this treatment, however.** This
" Code § 62(a).
^ See Rev. Proc. 90-64, 1990-53 I.R.B. 27, for the standard deductions in effect for 1991.
'^ Code § 67. This requirement reversed the earlier trend to conform the treatment of
employees and self-employed persons as much as possible.
^ Code § 62(c); Treas. Reg. § 1.62-2; cf. Treas. Reg. § 1.132-5(a)(l)(v) (similar rules for
working-condition fringe benefits). Somewhat different accounting rules apply depending on
whether the expense is subject to the substantiation requirements of section 274(d), and whether
the arrangement is a per diem or mileage plan. See Code § 62(c); Treas. Reg. §§ 1.62 -2(e) and
1.274-5T(g)and 0).
69
prevents employees from excluding from income amounts greater than that which they could
have deducted.'^ Client reimbursements are always included in an independent contractor's
gross income, and the expenses for which they are made must be deducted. Inadequate
accounting by the independent contractor to the client is therefore generally irrelevant in this
context. **
Unlike independent contractors, employees may not deduct interest expenses incurred in
their trade or business of being an employee: such interest is considered a personal expense.'"
Entertainment expenses generally may not be deducted unless they satisfy the business
purpose requirements of section 274(a). The rules applicable to employees and their employers
on the one hand and independent contractors and their clients on the other are about the same
for this purpose.'* Special exemptions are provided, however, for food or beverages furnished
on an employer's business premises primarily for its own employees, and for recreational or
'* Excess reimbursements must be returned to the employer. If the accounting requirements
are not met, the employee may still be able to deduct the underlying expenses. They will,
however, be subject to the two-percent floor. In addition, failure to account will shift the burden
of complying with various requirements of section 274, including the business purpose
requirement of section 274(a), the substantiation requirement of section 274(d), and the 80-
percent deduction limit of section 274(n), from the employer to the employee. Code
§ 274(e)(2), (e)(3)(A) and (n)(2)(A); Treas. Reg. §§ 1. 274-2 (f)(iv), 1.274-5T(0(2) and
31.3401(a)-4.
^ As with employees, however, if an independent contractor does not adequately account
to her client, the burden of complying with various requirements of section 274 will shift from
the client to her. Code § 274(e)(3)(B) and (e)(9); Treas. Reg. § 1.274-2(f)(2)(iv); see Treas.
Reg. § 1.274-5T(h)(3) for the definition of an adequate accounting for this purpose; see also
Treas. Reg. § 1.274-2(f)(2)(iv)(a) and (c)(1) (definitions of adequate accounting and
reimbursement arrangement). The substantiation requirements of section 274(d) are an
exception; an independent contractor continues to be subject to these requirements even if she
makes an adequate accounting to her client. See Treas. Reg. § 1.274-5T(h)(2); Rev. Proc. 63-4,
Q&A-28 and 29, 1963-1 C.B. 474; Smith v. Commissioner, 80 T.C. 1165 (1983). This
distinction presumably reflects the fact that, while employees generally need not deduct
reimbursed expenses because the reimbursements are simply excluded from their gross income,
independent contractors must generally deduct the amounts.
97
Code § 163(h)(2)(A).
'* See footnotes 95 and 96 above for rules relating to the allocation of the burden of
substantiation in the case of reimbursed expenses.
70
social activities primarily for their benefit.'' Independent contractors may, however, benefit
ft-om both as long as they are not provided primarily for the contractors' benefit.
Travel and entertainment expenses, business gifts, and expenses associated with "listed
property" (including automobiles, computers, cellular telephones and property used for
entertainment) also may not be deducted unless the taxpayer has adequate records or other
evidence to substantiate their amount and business purpose, within the meaning of section
274(d)."" Again, the rules applicable to employees and their employers on the one hand and
independent contractors and their clients on the other are about the same. Employers may use
certain simplified substantiation methods that are unavailable to clients of independent
contractors, however. In particular, they may rely on records maintained by their employees
with respect to the use of listed property, and they can avoid any substantiation requirements
with respect to the use of vehicles by adopting a policy statement prohibiting personal use and
meeting certain other requirements.'"' Presumably, these methods are denied to clients of
independent contractors because clients generally do not provide them with the property
necessary to perform their jobs, and, in any event, cannot supervise their use of the property
very closely.
Finally, business meal expenses generally may not be deducted unless the taxpayer or one
of its employees is present. Independent contractors may be treated as employees for this
purpose only if they render "significant services" to the taxpayer.'"^
Home office expenses and rental and depreciation expenses associated with listed property
(as described above) may be subject to special deduction limits unless they meet certain business
" Code § 274(e)(1) and (e)(4).
'°° See footnotes 95 and 96.
"" Treas. Reg. §§ 1.274-5T(e)(2)and 1.274-6T. The latter rule applies to both employees
and sole-proprietors. Treas. Reg. § 1.274-6T(e)(2)(i). The employer can also shift the burden
of compliance to its employees by treating the use of listed property as personal use and
including it in the employees' incomes without regard to the working condition fringe benefit
rules of section 132.
"" Code § 274(k); Staff of the Joint Committee on Taxation, l(X)th Cong., 1st Sess.,
General Explanation of the Tax Reform Act of 1986, 69 (Comm. Print 1987).
71
use requirements."" These limits were significantly tightened in TRA 1986. The limits for
employees and independent contractors are generally the same except that, in the case of home
office expenses, the employee's business use must also be "for the convenience of the
employer",'** and, in the case of listed property such as home computers, such use must be
"for the convenience of the employer and required as a condition of employment."'"* These
standards are difficult for many employees to meet.'*
Fringe Benefits. Independent contractors are generally not taken into account under the
employee fringe benefit provisions of the Code. On the one hand, this means that independent
contractors' clients generally are not required to include them in any pension or welfare benefit
plans they provide for their employees in order to maintain the plans' tax-qualified status, and
the independent contractors have correspondingly greater freedom to structure their own benefit
arrangements. On the other hand, this means that independent contractors may be unable to
participate in such plans even if they want to (and their clients agree), and some of the benefit
arrangements they establish for themselves as sole proprietors or partners may not be tax-
favored. (Such arrangements may also be more costly, since they usually cannot benefit from
the economies that some employers able to achieve through group purchase arrangements.)
The Code provides tax-favored treatment for a wide range of common employee fringe
benefits, including pension plans, life insurance and health and accident plans. In many cases,
such treatment is not available for benefits provided to highly compensated workers unless the
employer also provides comparable benefits to a minimum number of its nonhighly compensated
workers. Generally, only an employer's common law employees (and individuals treated as such
'°' See generally Code §§ 280A and 280F. Generally, in the case of a home office, the
space must be used exclusively on a regular basis as the taxpayer's principal place of business.
In the case of listed property, the property must be used predominantly (i.e., more than 50
percent of the time) in the taxpayer's trade or business.
'»* See Code § 280A(c)(l).
"» See § 280F(d)(3)(A); Treas. Reg. § 1.280F-6T(a)(2).
'°* See, e.g. , Rev. Rul. 86-129, 1986-2 C.B. 48. On the other hand, the Tax Court's "focal
point" test has made it difficult for independent contractors to establish their home office as their
principal place of business if they render services elsewhere. E.g., Bate v. Commissioner, lA
T.C. 105 (1980); but see Soliman v. Commissioner, 94 T.C. 20 (1990) (apparent abandonment
of "focal point" test).
72
under the Code)''" are taken into account for this purpose. In addition, these same provisions
generally prohibit an employer from offering tax-favored benefits to its independent contractors.
A list of tax-favored benefits, and the conditions under which they may be offered to employees
and independent contractors, are shown in Table A-1."* (The table does not include
statutorily-required benefits such as workers' compensation.)
Taken together, these rules tend to encourage employers to admit a new worker into an
existing fringe benefit plan if she is classified as an employee, and to discourage (if not actually
prohibit) them from doing so if she is classified as an independent contractor. Classification as
an independent contractor may, therefore, be beneficial to the client; in cases where the worker
would prefer additional cash or a different benefit package to the fringe benefits offered under
the employer's plan and can negotiate to receive some or all of the compensation the client
would otherwise have spent on the benefits, classification as an independent contractor may also
be beneficial to the worker.
An independent contractor who is unable to participate in her client's plans generally can
establish her own benefit arrangements in her capacity as a sole proprietor (or as a partner, if
she is in business with other individuals)."" As indicated in Table A-1, the most significant
types of fringe benefits may be available on a tax-favored basis. For example, sole proprietors
can generally establish their own pension plans, subject to essentially the same rules as
'"^ These include leased employees subject to section 414(n) and so-called "statutory
employees" treated under sections 3121(d) and 7701(a)(20) as employees for purposes of PICA
and certain employee benefit provisions of the Code. Cf. Staff of the Joint Committee on
Taxation, 100th Cong., 1st Sess., General Explanation of the Tax Reform Act of 1986, 1345
(Comm. Print 1987) (section 1706 not to affect application of section 414(n)). Note that, in
some cases employees may also be deemed to be self-employed. See, e.g. , Code § 1372 (certain
S corporation shareholders treated as partners).
108 Provisions that merely specify the accounting treatment of benefits provided to
employees, and do not grant tax-favored treatment, generally also apply to independent
contractors. E.g., Code §§ 83, 280G and 457; Treas. Reg. §§ 1.83-l(a)(l) and 1.457-2(d);
Prop. Treas. Reg. § 1.280G-1, Q&A-15.
"" Sole proprietors and partners are proprietors of unincorporated businesses. The
treatment of proprietors of incorporated businesses is discussed in section II. C. below.
Table A-1
Tax-Favored Benefits Available to Employees and Independent Contractors
Availability
Benefits
To Employee
in Emnlover's Plan
May be required
To Independent
Contractor in Client's
Plan
To Independent
Contractor in Own Plan
Employee achievement awards'
Group-term life insurance''
May be required
Death benefits"
Generally optional
Accident and health insurance'
Generally optional
Limited deduction only
Tuition remission*
May be required
Meals and lodging'
Optional
Group legal services'
May be required
Optional
Cafeteria plans'
May be required
Educational assistance*
May be required
Optional
Dependent care^
May be required
Optional
No-additional-cost fringes'
May be required
Optional
Qualified employee discount^
May be required
Optional
Working condition fringes"
Optional
Optional
Optional
De minimis fringes"
Generally optional
Optional
Optional
Free parking
Optional
Optional
On-premises athletic facilities''
Optional
Optional
New-product testing
Optional
Optional
Qualified pensions and annuities
May be required
Optional
Tax-sheltered annuities
May be required
Qualified and incentive stock option^
Optional
Employee stock purchase plans'
May be required
Voluntary employees' beneficiary
associations"
May be required
Dqjanmcnt of Ibc Treasury
Office of Tax Policy
In this table, "optional" means that the benefit is not required to be provided under any minimum coverage or nondiscrimination rules,
while "may be required" means that it may have to be provided.
Notes
a. Code §§ 74(c) and 2740)(3)(B).
b. Code § 79(d); Treas. Reg. § 1.79-0(b).
c. Code § 101(b)(3)(A); Treas. Reg. § 1.101-2(0(1). Discrimination rules may apply if the benefiU are provided under a qualified
pension plan, however.
d. Code §§ 105(g), 106, and 162(1)(1); Trcas. Reg. 5 1.105-l(a). Coverage and discrimination requirements may apply if the plan
is self-funded. Code § lOS(h).
e. Codes 117(d)(2)(A).
f. Code§ 119.
g. Code § 120(c)(1), (c)(2) and (d)(1).
h. Code § 125(b)(1) and (d)(1)(A); Prop. Treas. Reg. § 1.125-1, Q&A-4.
i. Code § 127(b)(2) and (c)(2); Treas. Reg. § 1.127-2(h)(l)(iii).
j. Code § 129(d)(2). (d)(3), (d)(8) and (e)(3).
k. Code § 132(b), (f) and (h)(1); Treas. Reg. § 1.132-l(b)(l)and (3).
1. Code § 132(c), (0 and (h)(1); Treas. Reg. § 1.132-l(b)(l)and (3).
m. Code § 132(d); Treas. Reg. § 1.1 32- 1(b)(2) and (4).
n. Code § 132(e); Treas. Reg. § 1 . 132-l(b)(2) and (4). Certain nondiscr'miination rules apply to eating facilities, however.
o. Code § 132(h)(4); Treas. Reg. § 1.132-(b)(2) (Hush language).
p. Code § 132(h)(5); Treas. Reg. § 1.132-l(b)(l)and (3).
q. Treas. Reg. §§ 1.132- 1(b)(2) (Hush language) and 1.132-5(n).
r. Code §§ 401(a)(4), 401(c) and 410(b); Treas. Reg. |§ I.72-17(a) and 1.401-10(b).
s. Code § 403(b); Treas. Reg. § 1.403(b)-l(a)(l).
t. Code §§ 421-22A; Treas. Reg. § 1.421-7(h).
u. Code § 423; Treas. Reg. § 1.423-2(e)(2).
V. Code § 501(c)(9); Treas. Reg. § 1.501(c)(9)-2(b).
75
employer- sponsored plans. "° In lieu of the exclusion from income for employer-provided
accident and health insurance, they can often deduct up to one-quarter of their medical insurance
expenses, without regard to the 7.5 percent floor in section 213 (unless they are covered under
an employer- sponsored plan directly or through their spouse).'" They can also provide
themselves certain fringe benefits, including working condition and de minimis fringes, on a pre-
tax basis. Other benefits must generally be purchased out of after-tax income. In addition, as
explained in Section II above, the tax benefits for sole proprietor and partnership plans are
generally limited to the income tax provisions of the Code, and do not apply for Social Security
and Medicare tax purposes.
C. Determination of Employee Status
The status of an individual as an employee or independent contractor for purposes of the
Federal tax laws is, with few exceptions, determined under the common law tests for
determining whether a master- servant (employment) relationship exists.
Background. The common law tests first assumed importance under the employment tax
provisions of the Code. The original Social Security Act simply defined an "employee" as
including "an officer of a corporation"."^ Treasury regulations issued in 1936 used common
law standards to determine employee status."^ The lower courts, however, applied a variety
of different standards, some relying less than others on common law precedents."* In 1947
"° In a sense these rules are more favorable: plans of sole proprietors who have no
nonhighly compensated employees resemble elective arrangements like IRAs and section 401(k)
plans, but are subject to higher dollar limits on contributions.
"* Code § 1620)(6), as amended by OBRA 1990 § 11410. This provision is due to expire
December 31, 1991, however.
"2 Social Security Act § 1101(a)(6), Pub. L. No. 74-271, 49 Stat. 620, 647 (1935). PICA
was in Title VIII of the original act. SECA was enacted on August 28, 1950.
"' Reg. 91, article 3, 1 Fed. Reg. 2049, 2052 (Nov. 11, 1936). The regulations state, inter
alia, that "[i]n general, if an individual is subject to the control or direction of another merely
as to the result to be accomplished by the work and not as to the means and methods for
accomplishing the result, he is an independent contractor. An individual performing services
as an independent contractor is not as to such services an employee." This closely resembles
the language in the current regulations.
"" See United States v. Webb, 397 U.S. 179 (1969), for a description of this case law.
76
the Supreme Court issued a pair of opinions that attempted to clarify the governing stan-
dards."* In them, the Court applied an "economic reality" test that resembled the common
law tests, under which "employees are those who as a matter of economic reality are dependent
on the business to which they render services.""*
The IRS (and the Social Security Administration) proposed amendments to their
regulations to incorporate the Court's new economic reality test, but these never took effect:
Congress reacted immediately by passing (over President Truman's veto) the so-called Gearhart
Resolution, endorsing the use of common law tests.'"
Current Rules. Current Treasury regulations provide that an individual is generally an
employee if, under the usual common law tests, the relationship between the individual and the
person for whom she performs services is the legal relationship of employer and employee.
Such a relationship generally exists if the person for whom the services are performed
has the right to control and direct the individual who performs the services, not
only as to the result to be accomplished by the work but also as to the details and
means by which that result is accomplished. That is, an employee is subject to
the will and control of the employer not only as to what shall be done but [also]
how it shall be done."*
Over the years, the IRS has identified 20 important factors for determining when the common
law tests are satisfied."' These factors, which are listed in Appendix B, are used in resolving
issues raised in rulings and other guidance, including guidance on the status of tech..ical services
"' Banks v. Birmingham, 332 U.S. 126 (1947), and United States v. Silk, 331 U.S. 704
(1947). See also Harrison v. Greyvan Lines, 331 U.S. 126 (1947).
"* Bartles, 332 U.S. at 130.
"^ H.R.J. Res. 296, Pub. L. No. 642, 62 Stat. 438 (1948).
"» Treas. Reg. §§ 3 1.3 12 1(d)- 1(a)(2), 31.3306(i)-l(b) and 31.3401(c)-l(b).
"' Internal Revenue Manual 4600 (Employment Tax Procedures), Exhibit 4640-1; see also
Rev. Rul. 87-41, 1987-1 C.B. 296. These factors were originally compiled by the Social
Security Administration in determining entitlement to benefits.
77
workers issued after the enactment of section 1706.'^° No one factor on this list is determina-
tive, though some are more important than others.
Congress and the courts have overridden the common law tests in some situations. For
example, certain occupations generally performed by employees are nevertheless treated as
performed by independent contractors under the Code; these include certain door-to-door
salesmen and real estate agents.'^' Conversely, certain occupations generally performed by
independent contractors are nevertheless treated as performed by employees for employment tax
purposes. These "statutory employees" include certain full-time life insurance salesmen, agent-
drivers and commission-drivers engaged in the distribution of specific kinds of products,
homeworkers and traveling or city salesmen.'^
Relevance of Incorporation. An employee generally cannot change her status for Federal
tax purposes to that of an independent contractor via incorporation. The common law tests focus
on the relationship between the individual performing the services and the service-recipient; if
an employment relationship exists, it is generally irrelevant whether payments are made directly
or through a corporation controlled by the individual.'^ The legislative history of section
1706 reiterates this point. '^^
'^° See Rev. Rul. 87-41, 1987-1 C.B. 296. See also Moore, Defining the Employee:
Common-Law Rules, Direction, February, 1988, at 13. Mr. Moore is the technical assistant for
Federal employment tax in the Office of the Assistant Chief Counsel (Employee Benefits and
Exempt Organizations) of the IRS. See generally Annotation, Determination of Employer-
Employee Relationship for Social Securiry Contribution and Unemployment Tax Purposes, 37
A.L.R. Fed. 95 (1978), and Annotation, What Constitutes Employer-Employee Relationship for
Purposes of Federal Income Tax Withholding, 51 A.L.R. Fed. 59 (1981).
'2' See Code § 3508; see also Code § 1372.
'22 See Code § 3121(d); Treas. Reg. § 31.3121(d)-l(d); Rev. Rul. 90-93, 1990-45 I.R.B.
4. Full-time life insurance salesmen may also be treated as employees for certain fringe benefit
purposes. Code § 7701(a)(20).
'23 E.g., Sargent v. Commissioner, 93 T.C. 572 (1989); Rev. Rul. 87-41, 1987-1 C.B. 296;
and Rev. Rul. 74-330, 1974-2 C.B. 278 (examples (1) and (2)).
'2^ H.R. Conf Rep. No. 841, 99th Cong., 2d Sess. 11-835 (1986); 132 Cong. Rec. S8088-
89 (June 20, 1986); see Rev. Rul. 87-41, 1987-1 C.B. 296; and Private Letter Ruling 9002017
(October 12, 1989).
78
An independent contractor also generally cannot change her status for Federal tax
purposes to that of an employee of her client via incorporation; she may, however, be treated
as an employee of her own personal service corporation for certain purposes, and derive certain
tax benefits as a result. The effect depends on whether the personal service corporation elects
to be taxed as a Subchapter S corporation under section 1362 of the Code. If it does not, the
individual will generally be treated as an employee of the corporation for tax purposes, and can
thus take advantage, imer alia, of various employee benefit provisions of the Code. She will,
moreover, not be subject to the two-percent floor on itemized deductions or other limits on
employee trade or business expense deductions to the extent she causes such expenses to be
deducted at the corporate level. Although any income received and retained by the corporation
will be taxed at (usually higher) corporate rates, in practice this problem can be minimized by
distributing as much income as possible in the form of compensation.
If the personal service corporation does elect to be taxed as an S corporation, the
individual will also generally be treated as an employee of the corporation for tax purposes,'^*
but with one important exception: assuming her ownership interest exceeds two percent, she
will not be treated as a employee for purposes of the employee benefit provisions of the
Code.'^* The treatment of trade or business expenses is roughly the same as for a C
corporation.'^
m. OTHER LAWS
A. Federal Labor Laws
Most Federal labor laws apply only to employees and do not protect independent
contractors. This is generally beneficial to the independent contractors' clients, who may save
the direct costs of providing additional benefits to the individuals plus any associated
administrative costs, but may not be beneficial to the independent contractors unless they do not
need the protection and can share in their clients' cost savings.
125
126
127
See Spicer Accounting, Inc. v. Vnited States, 918 F.2d 90 (9th Cir. 1990).
Code § 1372.
Code § 67(c); Temp. Treas. Reg. § 1.67-2T(b).
79
COBRA. Employers must generally give their employees and the employees'
beneficiaries the right to continue coverage under an employer-sponsored health plan after their
coverage has ceased, if coverage ceases on account of certain qualifying events.'^* This
requirement applies to employees and independent contractors (provided the plan covers at least
some common law employees).'^'
ERISA. Pension and welfare benefit plans are subject to various coverage, funding,
fiduciary, reporting, and other requirements under the Employee Retirement Income Security
Act of 1974.''° These labor provisions of ERISA do not apply to plans benefiting self-
employed individuals (including independent contractors) unless they also cover employees, and
many of the specific protections provided under ERISA extend only to employee-partici-
pants."' The tax provisions of ERISA are included in the Code.
Other Labor Laws. Independent contractors are generally not covered by the National
Labor Relations Act, and therefore generally may not engage in collective bargaining or similar
protected activities.''^ They also receive no protection under the nondiscrimination require-
ments of the Age Discrimination in Employment Act'" or Title VII of the Civil Rights Act
'^* Code § 4980B, as added by the Consolidated Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of
1985 (COBRA), Pub. L. No. 99-272, Title X, 100 Stat. 222 (1986), and amended by TAMRA
§3011.
'^' Code § 4980B(f)(7); Prop. Treas. Reg. § 1.162-26, Q«&A-16(b).
"° Pub. L. No. 93-406, 88 Stat. 829 (1974), codified at 29 U.S.C. §§ 1001 et seq.
'" ERISA §§ 3(3) and (6), 4(a) and 4021(a), 29 U.S.C. §§ 1002(3) and (6), 1003(a) and
1321(a); 29 C.F.R. § 2510.3-3.
"2 NLRA § 7, 29 U.S.C. § 157. See North American Van Lines, Inc. v. NLRB, 869 F.2d
596 (2d Cir. 1989).
'" ADEA §§ 4(a) and (11), 29 U.S.C. §§ 623(a) and 630(0- See Hyland v. New Haven
Radiology Assocs., P.C, 794 F.2d 793 (2d Cir. 1986).
80
of 1964,''* the safety requirements of the Occupational Safety and Health Act,"^ or the
minimum wage and overtime requirements of the Fair Labor Standards Act,'^ among others.
B. Patent and Copyright Laws
An employer is generally considered the author of any work prepared during the course
of an employee's employment for purposes of the Federal copyright laws; no such presumption
exists with respect to work prepared by independent contractors."' By contrast, generally no
legal distinction is drawn between employees and independent contractors under the Federal
patent laws.''* In practice, however, independent contractors may find it somewhat easier to
secure patent protection for on-the-job creations than employees, since this issue often turns on
a court's analysis of the implicit bargain struck between the parties.'''
C. State Laws
Many State laws also impose different requirements on employers and employees on the
one hand and independent contractors and their clients on the other. In particular, employers
are generally required to contribute a portion of the wages paid to each of their employees to
"* CivU Rights Act (1964) § 701(f), 42 U.S.C. §§ 2000e(f). See Wheeler v. Hurdman, 825
F.2d 257 (10th Cir.), cert, denied, 484 U.S. 986 (1987).
'" OSHA §§ 3(6) and 5(a)(1), 29 U.S.C. §§ 652(6) and 654(a)(1).
"* FLSA §§ 3(e)(1), 6 and 7, 29 U.S.C. §§ 203(e)(1), 206 and 207. See Walling v.
Portland Terminal Co. , 330 U.S. 148 (1947). Recent legislation has created an exemption from
FLSA for technical services workers who are employees. Pub. L. No. 101-583, 104 Stat. 2781
(1990).
'" Copyright Act §§ 101 and 201(b), 17 U.S.C. §§ 101 and 201(b) (work-for-hire). See.
e.g., CCNVv. Reid, 104 L.Ed.2d 831 (1989); and Aldon Accessories Ltd. v. Speigel, Inc., 738
F.2d 548, 552 (2d Cir.), cert, denied, 469 U.S. 982 (1984).
"* See, e.g., Francklyn v. Guilford Packing Co., 695 F.2d 1158, 1160-61 (9th Cir. 1983);
and B.F. Gladding <&. Co. v. Scientific Anglers, Inc., 248 F.2d 483 (6th Cir. 1957).
'" This is especially true of the so-called "shop right" doctrine, under which an employer
or client may claim royalty-free use of an invention. See, e.g., Hobbs v. United States, 376
F.2d 488, 495 (5th Cir. 1967), and Crom v. Cement Gun Co., 46 F. Supp. 403, 404 (D. Del.
1942).
81
State workers' compensation and unemployment funds. '^ Clients of independent contractors
generally are not required to do so, and, as a consequence, independent contractors generally
are not eligible for benefits under these systems. Employee wages may also be protected under
State wage payment laws, while payments to independent contractors are not.'"" As with
Federal labor laws, this exclusion is generally beneficial to the clients of independent
contractors, but may not be beneficial to the independent contractors themselves unless they do
not need the protection and can share in their clients' cost savings.
D. Determination of Employee Status
The status of an individual as an employee or independent contractor for purposes of
Federal and State labor and other laws is generally determined under standards that resemble the
control-based common law standards applied under the Code.'''^ Depending on the purpose
of the law involved, however, different factors are often emphasized in making this determina-
tion.'''^ Thus, IRS determinations of employee status are generally persuasive but not
""^ See, e.g., N.Y. Workmen's Compensation Law § 210 (McKinney 1965), and N.Y.
Labor Law §§ 560 and 570 (McKinney 1988) (unemployment insurance). See also text
accompanying footnote 80 above.
"' See, e.g., N.Y. Workmen's Compensation Law § 50 (McKinney 1965) (requirement that
employer provide security for payment of wage compensation).
'"•^ See generally Annotation, Trucker as Indepeiident Contractor or Employee Under § 2(3)
of the National Labor Relations Act (29 U.S.C.S. § 152(3)), 55 A.L.R. Fed. 20 (1990);
Annotation, Determination of "Independent Contractor' and "Employee' Status for Purposes of
§ 3(e)(1) of the Fair Labor Standards Act (29 U.S.C.S. § 203(e)(1)), 51 A.L.R. Fed. 702
(1990); Annotation, Who is 'Employee" Within the Meaning of Age Discrimination in
Employment Act (29 U.S.C.S. §§ 621-634), 69 A.L.R. Fed. 700 (1990); Annotation, Who is
"Employee" as Defined in § 701(f) of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, 42 U.S.C.S. § 2000e(f), 72
A.L.R. Fed. 522 (1990); and Annotation, Right to unemployment compensation or social security
of one working on his own projects or activities, 65 A.L.R.2d 1182 (1990).
"' Federal law: see, e.g., Darden v. Nationwide Mutual Ins. Co., 796 F.2d 701 (4th Cir.
1986) (ERISA); Weisel v. Singapore Joint Vemure, Inc., 602 F.2d 1185 (5th Cir. 1979); Dunlop
V. Dr. Pepper-Pepsi Cola Bottling Co., 529 F.2d 298 (6th Cir. 1976) (NLRA); Brennan v.
Gilles <& Cotting, Inc., 504 F.2d 1255 (4th Cir. 1974) (OSHA); Spirides v. Reinhardt, 613 F.2d
826 (D.C. Cir. 1979) (Title VII); and EEOC v. Zippo Mfg. Co., 713 F.2d 32 (3d Cir. 1983)
(ADEA).
State law: see, e.g., Taylor v. Employmem Division, 597 P.2d 780 (Or. 1978);
Starinieri, v. Unemployment Compensation Board of Review, 289 A. 2d 726 (Pa. 1972); and
82
determinative, and, in some cases, a worker can simultaneously be an employee for some
purposes and an independent contractor for others.
IV. SUMMARY
Current law does not consistently favor employee or independent contractor status.
Independent contractors and their clients are treated somewhat more favorably with respect to
employment taxes, and significantly more favorably with respect to their trade or business
expense deductions. On the other hand, employees and employers are treated more favorably
with respect to the taxation of some fringe benefits. Similarly, clients of independent contractors
do not bear as great a burden as employers under Federal and State labor laws, but independent
contractors also do not enjoy the same benefits or protections under those laws as do employees.
Laeng v. Workmen's Compensation Appeals Board, 494 P. 2d 1100 (Cal. 1972); cf. Gumming
V. District Unemployment Compensation Board, 382 A.2d 1010 (D.C. 1977) (self-employed
status does noi per se disqualify claimant).
APPENDIX B
COMMON LAW FACTORS USED TO DETERMINE EMPLOYEE STATUS
Workers are generally considered employees for Federal tax purposes if they:
1. Must comply with employer's instructions about the work.
2. Receive training from or at the direction of the employer.
3. Provide services that are integrated into the business.
4. Provide services that must be rendered personally.
5. Hire, supervise, and pay assistants for the employer.
6. Have a continuing working relationship with the employer.
7. Must follow set hours of work.
8. Work full-time for an employer.
9. Do their work on the employer's premises.
10. Must do their work in a sequence set by the employer.
1 1 . Must submit regular reports to the employer.
12. Receive payments of regular amounts at set intervals.
13. Receive payments for business and/or travelling expenses.
14. Rely on the employer to furnish tools and materials.
15. Lack a major investment in facilities used to perform the service.
16. Cannot make a profit or suffer a loss from their services.
17. Work for one employer at a time.
18. Do not offer their services to the general public.
19. Can be fired by the employer.
20. May quit work at any time without incurring liability.
Source: Exhibit 4640-1, Internal Revenue Manual 4600 (Employment Tax Procedures), and
Rev. Rul. 87-41, 1987-1 C.B. 296.
83
APPENDIX C
ADDITIONAL BACKGROUND TO TCMP AND SVC-1
I. TCMP
The definition of "technical services worker" for purposes of Table 5-2 is based on the
occupation of the primary taxpayer determined in the course of the TCMP audit. Unweighted
frequencies for the occupations included in the analysis are as follows:
Frequency Occupation
102 Architects
1,327 Engineers
27 Surveyors and Mapping Scientists
79 Computer Scientists
204 Operations and Systems Researchers and Analysts
8 Mathematical Scientists
182 Physical Scientists
27 Life Scientists
176 Engineering Technologists and Technicians
94 Drafting Occupations
1 1 Survey and Mapping Technicians
8 Biological Technologists and Technicians (Except Health)
39 Chemical and Nuclear Technologists and Technicians
4 Mathematical Technicians
47 Science Technologists and Technicians, Not Elsewhere Classi-
fied
12 Air Traffic Controllers
13 Radio and Related Operators
6 Legal Technicians
98 Programmers
4 Technical Writers
216 Technicians, Not Elsewhere Classified
2,684 Total
85
86
n. svc-i
Unweighted frequencies for the "technical services" occupations included in the SVC-1
survey are as follows:
Frequency
Occupation
1
8
4
10
5
15
43
Architects
Engineers
Physical Scientists
Engineering Technologists and Technicians
Air and Ship Officers and Technicians
Technicians, e.g., Embalmer/Morticians, Radio Operator,
Computer Programmer
Total
The following occupations were included in the TCMP analysis, but did not appear in the SVC-1
sample of misclassified employees:
Computer Scientists and Specialists;
Operations and System Researchers and Analysts;
Mathematical Scientists including Mathematicians, Actuaries and Statisticians,
Life Scientists;
Science Technologists and Mathematical Technicians.
■ ■IT UP
HAHY
Department of the Treasury
Washington, D.C. 20220
Official Business
Penalty for Private Use, $300
us, TREASURY LIBRARY
1 0085479